Andelius Ted C, Vestergaard Rikke F, Hauge Ellen M, Brüel Annemarie, Thomsen Jesper S, Honge Jesper L, Hjortdal Vibeke E
Department of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Surgery, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus N, Denmark
Department of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Surgery, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus N, Denmark.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2015 Dec;48(6):850-4. doi: 10.1093/ejcts/ezu528. Epub 2015 Jan 18.
Bone wax is frequently used to diminish bleeding after sternotomy. Water-soluble polymer wax has been shown to diminish postoperative bleeding and, unlike traditional bone wax, to be absorbed and removed by the organism in an unchanged state. We have previously shown that bone wax impairs early bone healing after sternotomy, whereas polymer wax does not. This difference was observed 6 weeks postoperatively and questions arose as to whether these effects were long term. Therefore, we hypothesized that bone wax impairs bone healing in sternotomized pigs 6 months postoperatively, whereas polymer wax does not.
Fourteen Landrace/Yorkshire pigs were sternotomized and then randomly assigned to haemostasis by either bone wax (WAX-group) or water-soluble polymer wax (POL-group). After 6 months, the pigs were euthanized and the sternum was removed and prepared for further assessment. Bone fracture strength and bone stiffness were determined using a modified three-point bending test, whereas bone healing was examined by means of quantitative histology. Six pigs died before the end of the study due to failure to thrive, valve prosthesis endocarditis and coronary artery occlusion.
The mechanical testing showed no difference between groups with regard to fracture strength [WAX-group versus POL-group; 214.8 (85.5-478.5) vs 203.8 (90.4-478.5) N, P = 0.986] or maximum stiffness [213.0 (81.5-409.5) vs 348.5 (23.3-689.5) N/mm, P = 0.128]. Histology showed predominance of fibroblast-covered surfaces [10.6% (1.8-23.3%) vs 4.1% (0.0-13.0%), P < 0.001] and fibrous tissue volume [45.4% (6.9-82.0%) vs 17.4% (2.9-55.0%), P < 0.001] in animals treated with bone wax. The volume fraction of calcified bone tended to be higher in the POL-group [26.8% (4.3-35.8%) vs 16.7% (1.5-35.8%), P = 0.065]. Granulomas comprised 12.5% (0.0-78.9%) of the volume fraction in the WAX-group compared with 0.0% (0.0-0.0%) in the POL-group (P < 0.001).
Bone wax and water-soluble polymer wax had similar long-term effects on bone mechanical properties. Histology confirmed our hypothesis and showed a more extensive foreign body reaction in animals treated with bone wax than in those treated with water-soluble polymer wax.
骨蜡常用于减少胸骨切开术后的出血。水溶性聚合物蜡已被证明可减少术后出血,并且与传统骨蜡不同,它能以不变的状态被机体吸收和清除。我们之前已经表明,骨蜡会损害胸骨切开术后的早期骨愈合,而聚合物蜡不会。这种差异在术后6周时被观察到,并且出现了这些影响是否为长期影响的问题。因此,我们假设骨蜡会损害胸骨切开术猪术后6个月的骨愈合,而聚合物蜡不会。
14只长白/约克夏猪接受胸骨切开术,然后随机分为使用骨蜡(WAX组)或水溶性聚合物蜡(POL组)进行止血。6个月后,对猪实施安乐死并取出胸骨,准备进行进一步评估。使用改良的三点弯曲试验测定骨折强度和骨刚度,而通过定量组织学检查骨愈合情况。6只猪在研究结束前因生长不良、人工瓣膜心内膜炎和冠状动脉阻塞死亡。
力学测试显示,两组在骨折强度方面无差异[WAX组与POL组;214.8(85.5 - 478.5)对203.8(90.4 - 478.5)N,P = 0.986]或最大刚度方面无差异[213.0(81.5 - 409.5)对348.5(23.3 - 689.5)N/mm,P = 0.128]。组织学显示,使用骨蜡治疗的动物中,成纤维细胞覆盖表面占优势[10.6%(1.8 - 23.3%)对4.1%(0.0 - 13.0%),P < 0.001]以及纤维组织体积占优势[45.4%(6.9 - 82.0%)对17.4%(2.9 - 55.0%),P < 0.001]。POL组钙化骨的体积分数倾向于更高[26.8%(4.3 - 35.8%)对16.7%(1.5 - 35.8%),P = 0.065]。肉芽肿在WAX组中占体积分数的12.5%(0.0 - 78.9%),而在POL组中为0.0%(0.0 - 0.0%)(P < 0.001)。
骨蜡和水溶性聚合物蜡对骨力学性能具有相似的长期影响。组织学证实了我们的假设,并显示使用骨蜡治疗的动物比使用水溶性聚合物蜡治疗的动物有更广泛的异物反应。