Shemer Avner, Levy Hanna, Sadick Neil S, Harth Yoram, Dorizas Andrew S
J Drugs Dermatol. 2014 Nov;13(11):1342-7.
In the last decade, energy-based aesthetic treatments, using light, radiofrequency (RF), and ultrasound, have gained scientific acceptance as safe and efficacious for non-invasive treatment for aesthetic skin disorders. The phase-controlled multisource radiofrequency technology (3DEEP™), which is based on the simultaneous use of multiple RF generators, was proven to allow significant pigment-independent dermal heating without pain or the need of epidermal cooling. This study was performed in order to evaluate the efficacy and safety of a new handheld device delivering multisource radiofrequency to the skin for wrinkle reduction and skin tightening in the home setting.
A total of 69 participants (age 54.3 years ± 8.09; age range 37-72 years) were enrolled in the study after meeting all inclusion/exclusion criteria (100%) and providing informed consent. Participants were provided with the tested device together with a user manual and treatment diary, to perform independent treatments at home for 4 weeks. The tested device, (Newa™, EndyMed Medical, Cesarea, Israel) emits 12 W of 1Mhz, RF energy through six electrodes arranged in a linear fashion. Independent control of RF polarity through each one of the 6 electrodes allows significant reduction of energy flow through the epidermis with increased dermal penetration. Participants were instructed to perform at least 5 treatments a week, for one month. Four follow-up visits were scheduled (once a week) during the period of independent treatments at home, following 4 weeks of home treatments, 1 month follow-up visit (1 month after treatment end) and at 3 months follow-up (3 months following treatment end). Analysis of pre-and post treatment images was conducted by three uninvolved physicians experienced with the Fitzpatrick Wrinkle and Elastosis Scale. Fitzpatrick Wrinkle and Elastosis score of each time point (4 weeks following home use treatments; 1 month follow-up, 3 months follow-up) was compared to baseline. Participants were asked a series of questions designed to explore usability concerns and level of satisfaction regarding the device use and subjective efficacy.
Altogether, 62 subjects completed the study course and follow-up visits. No unexpected adverse effects were detected or reported throughout the independent treatment. All study participants did not experience any difficulties while operating the tested device for independent wrinkle reduction treatments. Photographic analysis of pre- and post-one month of independent home use treatments, and one and three months follow-up after end of treatment course, was conducted by three uninvolved board certified dermatologists. Analysis of results revealed improvement (downgrade of at least 1 score according to the Fitzpatrick scale) in 91.93%, 96.77%, and 98.39% of study subjects (according to the first, second, and third reviewer, respectively). Results were found to be statistically significant. The majority of study participants were very satisfied from the results of the independent treatment using the tested device for wrinkle reduction.
在过去十年中,基于光、射频(RF)和超声的能量型美容治疗已在科学上被认可为治疗美容性皮肤疾病的安全有效非侵入性方法。基于同时使用多个射频发生器的相控多源射频技术(3DEEP™)已被证明可实现显著的与色素无关的真皮加热,且无痛或无需表皮冷却。本研究旨在评估一种新型手持设备在家庭环境中向皮肤输送多源射频以减少皱纹和紧致皮肤的疗效和安全性。
共有69名参与者(年龄54.3岁±8.09;年龄范围37 - 72岁)在满足所有纳入/排除标准(100%)并提供知情同意后纳入研究。为参与者提供测试设备以及用户手册和治疗日记,以便他们在家中进行4周的独立治疗。测试设备(Newa™,EndyMed Medical,以色列凯撒利亚)通过以线性方式排列的六个电极发射12W的1MHz射频能量。通过6个电极中的每一个独立控制射频极性可显著减少通过表皮的能量流,同时增加真皮穿透。参与者被指示每周至少进行5次治疗,持续1个月。在家庭独立治疗期间安排了4次随访(每周一次),在家庭治疗4周后、治疗结束后1个月随访以及治疗结束后3个月随访。由三名熟悉菲茨帕特里克皱纹和弹性组织量表的不相关医生对治疗前后的图像进行分析。将每个时间点(家庭使用治疗后4周;1个月随访、3个月随访)的菲茨帕特里克皱纹和弹性组织评分与基线进行比较。向参与者询问了一系列旨在探讨关于设备使用的可用性问题、满意度以及主观疗效的问题。
共有62名受试者完成了研究过程和随访。在整个独立治疗过程中未检测到或报告意外不良事件。所有研究参与者在操作测试设备进行独立的皱纹减少治疗时均未遇到任何困难。由三名不相关的皮肤科专科医生对独立家庭使用治疗1个月前后以及治疗过程结束后1个月和3个月随访的照片进行分析。结果分析显示,91.93%、96.77%和98.39%的研究受试者(分别根据第一位、第二位和第三位评审员)有改善(根据菲茨帕特里克量表至少降低1分)。结果具有统计学意义。大多数研究参与者对使用测试设备进行皱纹减少的独立治疗结果非常满意。