Taveira-Gomes Tiago, Prado-Costa Rui, Severo Milton, Ferreira Maria Amélia
Department of Medical Education and Simulation, Faculty of Medicine of the University of Porto, Porto, Portugal.
ALERT Life Sciences Computing, Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal.
BMC Med Educ. 2015 Jan 24;15:4. doi: 10.1186/s12909-014-0275-0.
Spaced-repetition and test-enhanced learning are two methodologies that boost knowledge retention. ALERT STUDENT is a platform that allows creation and distribution of Learning Objects named flashcards, and provides insight into student judgments-of-learning through a metric called 'recall accuracy'. This study aims to understand how the spaced-repetition and test-enhanced learning features provided by the platform affect recall accuracy, and to characterize the effect that students, flashcards and repetitions exert on this measurement.
Three spaced laboratory sessions (s0, s1 and s2), were conducted with n=96 medical students. The intervention employed a study task, and a quiz task that consisted in mentally answering open-ended questions about each flashcard and grading recall accuracy. Students were randomized into study-quiz and quiz groups. On s0 both groups performed the quiz task. On s1 and s2, the study-quiz group performed the study task followed by the quiz task, whereas the quiz group only performed the quiz task. We measured differences in recall accuracy between groups/sessions, its variance components, and the G-coefficients for the flashcard component.
At s0 there were no differences in recall accuracy between groups. The experiment group achieved a significant increase in recall accuracy that was superior to the quiz group in s1 and s2. In the study-quiz group, increases in recall accuracy were mainly due to the session, followed by flashcard factors and student factors. In the quiz group, increases in recall accuracy were mainly accounted by flashcard factors, followed by student and session factors. The flashcard G-coefficient indicated an agreement on recall accuracy of 91% in the quiz group, and of 47% in the study-quiz group.
Recall accuracy is an easily collectible measurement that increases the educational value of Learning Objects and open-ended questions. This metric seems to vary in a way consistent with knowledge retention, but further investigation is necessary to ascertain the nature of such relationship. Recall accuracy has educational implications to students and educators, and may contribute to deliver tailored learning experiences, assess the effectiveness of instruction, and facilitate research comparing blended-learning interventions.
间隔重复学习法和测试强化学习法是两种有助于提高知识留存率的方法。“ALERT STUDENT”是一个平台,它允许创建和分发名为抽认卡的学习对象,并通过一种名为“回忆准确率”的指标深入了解学生的学习判断。本研究旨在了解该平台提供的间隔重复学习法和测试强化学习功能如何影响回忆准确率,并描述学生、抽认卡和重复操作对这一测量结果的影响。
对96名医学生进行了三次间隔的实验室课程(s0、s1和s2)。干预措施包括一项学习任务和一项测验任务,测验任务要求学生在脑海中回答关于每张抽认卡的开放式问题并评定回忆准确率。学生被随机分为学习-测验组和测验组。在s0时,两组都进行了测验任务。在s1和s2时,学习-测验组先进行学习任务,然后进行测验任务,而测验组只进行测验任务。我们测量了组间/课程间回忆准确率的差异、其方差成分以及抽认卡成分的G系数。
在s0时,两组的回忆准确率没有差异。实验组在s1和s2时的回忆准确率显著提高,优于测验组。在学习-测验组中,回忆准确率的提高主要归因于课程,其次是抽认卡因素和学生因素。在测验组中,回忆准确率的提高主要由抽认卡因素导致,其次是学生和课程因素。抽认卡G系数表明,测验组在回忆准确率上的一致性为91%,学习-测验组为47%。
回忆准确率是一种易于收集的测量指标,它提高了学习对象和开放式问题的教育价值。这个指标的变化方式似乎与知识留存率一致,但需要进一步研究以确定这种关系的本质。回忆准确率对学生和教育工作者具有教育意义,可能有助于提供个性化的学习体验、评估教学效果以及促进比较混合学习干预措施的研究。