Occhionorelli S, Tartarini D, Cappellari L, Stano R, Vasquez G
G Chir. 2014 Nov-Dec;35(11-12):283-9.
Acute left-sided malignant colonic obstruction is common in elderly patients, in which emergency surgery is related with high morbidity and mortality rates, and often necessitates a two-step resection. Although the use of self-expanding metallic stents (SEMS) in elderly patients has not been adequately described yet, there are almost two international important trials which are still in progress, the stenting technique is established to be, by the international literature, an useful treatment with low morbidity and mortality. It's also a bridge to surgery, since the insertion of a SEMS can decompress the obstruction, making bowel and patient preparation possible and facilitating singlestage surgical resection. Palliative stenting can improve quality of life when compared to surgery in patients with metastasis or high co-morbidity. The aim of this study is to analyze mortality, avoidance of stoma, short- and long-term survival in patient with malignant left-sided large bowel obstruction who underwent to stent placement in our Emergency Surgery Unit, which is operative since November 2010 in our city Hospital in Ferrara.
Between November 2010 and December 2012 a total of 15 patients with acute left-sided malignant large bowel obstruction suitable for colonic stent application were admitted to Emergency Surgery Unit. Among these patients, 9 underwent to self-expanding metallic stent placement (group A), the other (group B) 6 patient underwent to emergency surgery. In this observational not-randomized study we analyzed the efficacy and safety of SEMS placement for patients either as a bridge to surgery or as a palliation, beside the short term and long term outcomes, versus those patients operated straight.
Self-expanding metallic stents were successfully implanted in 9 of the 15 patients with acute left-sided malignant large bowel obstruction. No acute procedure-related complication was observed. All the patients in group A kept the stent in place for an average of 7,7 days, then everyone underwent to surgery. A large bowel resection with one-time recanalization was performed in 8 of the 9 patients. None Hartmann resection was necessary. Only one underwent again to surgery because of a dehiscence, a stoma was necessary. Between the other 6 patients in group B who underwent directly to surgery, In one case was necessary an Hartmann resection, another one incurred in dehiscence of the anastomosis that required reoperation with stoma creation.
Placement of SEMS seems to be an useful alternative to emergent surgery in the management of acute left-sided bowel obstruction, both as a bridge to surgery and as a palliative procedure. SEMS can provide an effective and safe therapeutic option compared to emergency surgery, most of all in elderly patients, with a lower mortality rate, a significantly higher rate of primary anastomosis and the avoidance of stoma. However, to fully determine their role for these indications, more data and more high level evidence is required.
急性左侧恶性结肠梗阻在老年患者中很常见,急诊手术与之相关的发病率和死亡率较高,且常需分两步进行切除。尽管自膨式金属支架(SEMS)在老年患者中的应用尚未得到充分描述,但目前仍有两项国际重要试验正在进行中,根据国际文献,支架置入技术已被确立为一种发病率和死亡率较低的有效治疗方法。它也是手术的桥梁,因为插入SEMS可解除梗阻,使肠道和患者准备成为可能,并便于进行一期手术切除。与对有转移或高合并症患者进行手术相比,姑息性支架置入可改善生活质量。本研究的目的是分析在我们费拉拉市医院自2010年11月开始运作的急诊外科接受支架置入的左侧恶性大肠梗阻患者的死亡率、造口避免情况、短期和长期生存率。
2010年11月至2012年12月期间,共有15例适合应用结肠支架的急性左侧恶性大肠梗阻患者入住急诊外科。在这些患者中,9例接受了自膨式金属支架置入(A组),另外6例(B组)接受了急诊手术。在这项观察性非随机研究中,我们分析了SEMS置入作为手术桥梁或姑息治疗对患者的有效性和安全性,以及与直接手术患者相比的短期和长期结果。
15例急性左侧恶性大肠梗阻患者中有9例成功植入了自膨式金属支架。未观察到与手术相关的急性并发症。A组所有患者的支架平均留置7.7天,然后均接受了手术。9例患者中有8例行大肠切除并一次性再通。无需行Hartmann切除术。只有1例因吻合口裂开再次手术,有必要行造口术。在直接接受手术的B组其他6例患者中,1例需要行Hartmann切除术,另1例吻合口裂开,需要再次手术并造口。
在急性左侧肠梗阻的治疗中,SEMS置入似乎是急诊手术的一种有效替代方法,既作为手术桥梁,也作为姑息性手术。与急诊手术相比,SEMS可提供一种有效且安全的治疗选择,尤其是在老年患者中,死亡率更低,一期吻合率显著更高,且可避免造口。然而,要充分确定其在这些适应证中的作用,还需要更多数据和更高水平的证据。