Becker Richard A, Friedman Katie Paul, Simon Ted W, Marty M Sue, Patlewicz Grace, Rowlands J Craig
American Chemistry Council, 700 2nd St., NE, Washington, DC, United States.
Bayer CropScience LP, Research Triangle Park, NC, United States.
Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2015 Apr;71(3):398-408. doi: 10.1016/j.yrtph.2015.01.008. Epub 2015 Feb 3.
Rapid high throughput in vitro screening (HTS) assays are now available for characterizing dose-responses in assays that have been selected for their sensitivity in detecting estrogen-related endpoints. For example, EPA's ToxCast™ program recently released endocrine assay results for more than 1800 substances and the interagency Tox21 consortium is in the process of releasing data for approximately 10,000 chemicals. But such activity measurements alone fall short for the purposes of priority setting or screening because the relevant exposure context is not considered. Here, we extend the method of exposure:activity profiling by calculating the exposure:activity ratios (EARs) using human exposure estimates and AC50 values for a range of chemicals tested in a suite of seven estrogenic assays in ToxCast™ and Tox21. To provide additional context, relative estrogenic exposure:activity quotients (REEAQ) were derived by comparing chemical-specific EARs to the EAR of the ubiquitous dietary phytoestrogen, genistein (GEN). Although the activity of a substance in HTS-endocrine assays is not a measure of health hazard or risk, understanding how such a dose compares to human exposures provides a valuable additional metric that can be used in decision-making; substances with small EARs and REEAQs would indicate low priority for further endocrine screening or testing.
现在已有快速高通量体外筛选(HTS)试验,可用于在已因其对雌激素相关终点检测的敏感性而选定的试验中表征剂量反应。例如,美国环境保护局(EPA)的ToxCast™计划最近公布了1800多种物质的内分泌试验结果,跨部门的Tox21联盟也正在公布约10000种化学品的数据。但仅靠这种活性测量对于确定优先级或筛选目的来说是不够的,因为没有考虑相关的暴露背景。在此,我们扩展了暴露:活性分析方法,通过使用人类暴露估计值和在ToxCast™和Tox21的一组七种雌激素试验中测试的一系列化学品的半数效应浓度(AC50)值来计算暴露:活性比(EAR)。为提供更多背景信息,通过将特定化学品的EAR与普遍存在的膳食植物雌激素染料木黄酮(GEN)的EAR进行比较,得出相对雌激素暴露:活性商(REEAQ)。尽管一种物质在HTS - 内分泌试验中的活性并非健康危害或风险的衡量标准,但了解这种剂量与人类暴露的比较情况可提供一个有价值的额外指标,可用于决策;EAR和REEAQ较小的物质表明进一步进行内分泌筛选或测试的优先级较低。