Asimakopoulos P, Hathorn I, Monaghan H, Williams A T
Department of Otolaryngology,Head and Neck Surgery, University of Edinburgh Hospitals,Scotland,UK.
Department of Pathology,Edinburgh Royal Infirmary,Scotland,UK.
J Laryngol Otol. 2015 Mar;129(3):254-60. doi: 10.1017/S0022215115000213. Epub 2015 Feb 16.
There is no consensus as to whether all routine bilateral polypectomy specimens should be sent for formal histopathological diagnosis to exclude underlying neoplastic pathology. This study assessed the necessity for histopathological investigation as routine practice in cases of bilateral and unilateral nasal lesions by estimating the incidence of unexpected pathologies. It also evaluated the ability of computed tomography to predict histopathological diagnosis in patients with unilateral nasal lesions.
A retrospective analysis was conducted of 98 patients undergoing nasal polypectomy over a 12-month period.
Five of 23 patients with a unilateral lesion on nasendoscopy had inverted papillomas on histopathological examination. None of the 75 patients with clinically bilateral lesions on nasendoscopy showed evidence of neoplasia on histopathological examination. Patients with inverted papillomas had significantly lower total Lund-Mackay scores than those with bilateral polyps. Asymmetry scores of inverted papilloma patients were significantly higher compared to both bilateral and unilateral polyps patients.
The results suggest that histopathological diagnosis is only necessary in unilateral lesion patients as no unexpected histopathological diagnoses were made in bilateral lesion patients. Computed tomography imaging may have a role in predicting histopathological diagnosis by demonstrating asymmetry and less overall sinus opacification in patients with neoplastic lesions.
对于所有常规双侧息肉切除标本是否都应送去进行正式的组织病理学诊断以排除潜在的肿瘤性病变,目前尚无共识。本研究通过估算意外病变的发生率,评估了对双侧和单侧鼻腔病变患者进行组织病理学检查作为常规做法的必要性。它还评估了计算机断层扫描预测单侧鼻腔病变患者组织病理学诊断的能力。
对在12个月期间接受鼻息肉切除术的98例患者进行回顾性分析。
23例鼻内镜检查发现单侧病变的患者中,有5例组织病理学检查显示为内翻性乳头状瘤。75例鼻内镜检查显示临床双侧病变的患者中,没有一例在组织病理学检查中显示有肿瘤形成的证据。内翻性乳头状瘤患者的总Lund-Mackay评分显著低于双侧息肉患者。与双侧和单侧息肉患者相比,内翻性乳头状瘤患者的不对称评分显著更高。
结果表明,由于双侧病变患者未出现意外的组织病理学诊断,因此仅对单侧病变患者进行组织病理学诊断是必要的。计算机断层扫描成像可能通过显示肿瘤性病变患者的不对称性和总体鼻窦混浊程度较低,在预测组织病理学诊断方面发挥作用。