Lotfi Razieh, Tehrani Fahimeh Ramezani, Dovom Marzieh Rostami, Torkestani Farahnaz, Abedini Mehrandokht, Sajedinejad Sima
Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Alborz University of Medical Sciences, Karaj, Iran.
Reproductive Endocrinology Research Center, Research Institute for Endocrine Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Int J Prev Med. 2014 Dec;5(12):1552-66.
With the change in population policy from birth control toward encouraging birth and population growth in Iran, repeated cesarean deliveries as a main reason of cesarean section are associated with more potential adverse consequences. The aim of this research was to explore effective strategies to reduce cesarean delivery rates in Iran.
A mixed methodological study was designed and implemented. First, using a qualitative approach, concepts and influencing factors of increased cesarean delivery were explored. Based on the findings of this phase of the study, a questionnaire including the proposed strategies to reduce cesarean delivery was developed. Then in a quantitative phase, the questionnaire was assessed by key informants from across the country and evaluated to obtain more effective strategies to reduce cesarean delivery. Ten participants in the qualitative study included policy makers from the Ministry of Health, obstetricians, midwives and anthropologists. In the next step, 141 participants from private and public hospitals, insurance experts, Academic Associations of Midwifery, and policy makers in Maternity Health Affairs of Ministry of Health were invited to assess and provide feedback on the strategies that work to reduce cesarean deliveries.
Qualitative data analysis showed four concept related to increased cesarean delivery rates including; "standardization", "education", "amending regulations", and "performance supervision". Effective strategies extracted from qualitative data were rated by participants then, using ACCEPT derived from A as attainability, C as costing, C as complication, E as effectiveness, P as popularity, and T as timing table 19 strategies were detected as priorities.
Although developing effective strategies to reduce cesarean delivery rates is complex process because of the multi-factorial nature of increased cesarean deliveries, in this study we have achieved strategies that in the context of Iran could work.
随着伊朗人口政策从计划生育转向鼓励生育和人口增长,作为剖宫产主要原因的重复剖宫产与更多潜在不良后果相关。本研究的目的是探索降低伊朗剖宫产率的有效策略。
设计并实施了一项混合方法研究。首先,采用定性方法,探讨剖宫产增加的概念和影响因素。基于本研究阶段的结果,编制了一份包含降低剖宫产建议策略的问卷。然后在定量阶段,由来自全国各地的关键信息提供者对问卷进行评估,并进行评价以获得更有效的降低剖宫产策略。定性研究的10名参与者包括卫生部政策制定者、产科医生、助产士和人类学家。下一步,邀请了来自私立和公立医院的141名参与者、保险专家、助产士学术协会以及卫生部孕产妇健康事务政策制定者,对降低剖宫产的有效策略进行评估并提供反馈。
定性数据分析显示了与剖宫产率增加相关的四个概念,包括“标准化”“教育”“修订法规”和“绩效监督”。然后,参与者对从定性数据中提取的有效策略进行评分,使用从A得出的ACCEPT,其中A代表可实现性,C代表成本,C代表并发症,E代表有效性,P代表受欢迎程度,T代表时间表,确定了19项策略为优先事项。
尽管由于剖宫产增加的多因素性质,制定降低剖宫产率的有效策略是一个复杂的过程,但在本研究中,我们已经获得了在伊朗背景下可能有效的策略。