Seeman Ego, Martin T John
Departments of Medicine and Endocrinology, Austin Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
J Bone Miner Res. 2015 May;30(5):753-64. doi: 10.1002/jbmr.2496.
Co-administration of antiresorptive and anabolic therapies has appeal because these treatments target the two main abnormalities in bone remodeling responsible for bone loss and microstructural deterioration. Antiresorptives reduce the number of basic multicellular units (BMUs) remodeling bone and reduce the volume of bone each BMU resorbs. Intermittent parathyroid hormone (PTH) increases the volume of bone formed by existing BMUs and those generated by PTH administration. PTH also increases bone formation by stimulating the differentiation, maturation, and longevity of osteoblast lineage cells residing upon quiescent bone surfaces. Despite these rationally targeted actions, enthusiasm for this approach waned when combined therapy blunted the increase in areal bone mineral density (aBMD) relative to that produced by PTH. Although many studies have since reported additive effects of combined therapy, whatever the aBMD result (blunting, additive, or null), these outcomes give little, if any, insight into changes in bone's material composition or microstructure and give misleading information concerning the net effects on bone strength. Combined therapy remains a potentially valuable approach to therapy. Because studies of antifracture efficacy comparing combined with single therapy are unlikely to be performed in humans, efforts should be directed toward improving methods of quantifying the net effects of combined therapy on bone's material composition, microarchitecture, and strength.
抗吸收疗法和促合成疗法联合使用具有吸引力,因为这些治疗针对骨重塑中导致骨质流失和微结构恶化的两个主要异常情况。抗吸收药物减少了重塑骨骼的基本多细胞单位(BMU)数量,并减少了每个BMU吸收的骨量。间歇性甲状旁腺激素(PTH)增加了现有BMU以及PTH给药产生的BMU形成的骨量。PTH还通过刺激静止骨表面的成骨细胞谱系细胞的分化、成熟和寿命来增加骨形成。尽管有这些合理的靶向作用,但当联合治疗使面骨矿物质密度(aBMD)的增加相对于PTH产生的增加减弱时,对这种方法的热情就减弱了。尽管此后许多研究报告了联合治疗的相加作用,但无论aBMD结果如何(减弱、相加或无作用),这些结果几乎没有(如果有的话)揭示骨材料组成或微观结构的变化,并且给出了关于对骨强度的净效应的误导性信息。联合治疗仍然是一种潜在有价值的治疗方法。由于不太可能在人体中进行比较联合治疗与单一治疗的抗骨折疗效研究,因此应致力于改进量化联合治疗对骨材料组成、微结构和强度的净效应的方法。