Wright Nat, Bleakley Adam, Butt Christine, Chadwick Oliver, Mahmood Khaver, Patel Kiran, Salhi Aicha
Clinical Director, Prison Health Research, Leeds Community Healthcare NHS Trust, Leeds, UK.
Int J Prison Health. 2011;7(4):37-51. doi: 10.1108/17449201111256899.
The purpose of this paper is to review systematically the available literature relating to the implementation of peer education to promote health and healthy behaviour in prisons.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: The authors undertook a narrative systematic review of Medline, EMBASE, CINAHL, Psychinfo, Web of Science and Cochrane databases. Relevant journals and reference lists were hand searched for relevant articles to be included in the review. Of the abstracts found, full-text papers were retrieved for those papers deemed as possibly fulfilling the inclusion criteria of the review.
A total of 3,033 abstracts were identified leading to 46 full-text articles being retrieved, of which ten were included in the review. Peer education in prisons can have an impact on attitudes, knowledge, and behaviour intention regarding HIV risk behaviour. The research findings were inconclusive for the impact of peer education upon illicit drug use and injecting practice. There was a paucity of research evaluating the impact of peer education upon mental ill health, obesity, diet, smoking, or self-management of chronic physical diseases.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: Peer education is effective in reducing risk of HIV transmission. It is possible that peer education for mental health issues is stigmatising, presenting an opportunity for further research activity. The impact of peer education upon illicit drug use practice, obesity, diet, smoking, and self-management of chronic physical diseases also presents further research opportunities. Research evaluating models of active peer educator involvement in health service delivery and organisation is also lacking.
本文旨在系统回顾与在监狱中实施同伴教育以促进健康和健康行为相关的现有文献。
设计/方法/途径:作者对Medline、EMBASE、CINAHL、Psychinfo、科学引文索引和Cochrane数据库进行了叙述性系统综述。手动检索相关期刊和参考文献列表以查找纳入综述的相关文章。在找到的摘要中,检索了那些被认为可能符合综述纳入标准的论文的全文。
共识别出3033篇摘要,从中检索到46篇全文文章,其中10篇被纳入综述。监狱中的同伴教育可对关于艾滋病毒风险行为的态度、知识和行为意图产生影响。关于同伴教育对非法药物使用和注射行为的影响,研究结果尚无定论。评估同伴教育对精神疾病、肥胖、饮食、吸烟或慢性身体疾病自我管理影响的研究很少。
原创性/价值:同伴教育在降低艾滋病毒传播风险方面有效。针对心理健康问题的同伴教育可能存在污名化现象,这为进一步的研究活动提供了契机。同伴教育对非法药物使用行为、肥胖、饮食、吸烟和慢性身体疾病自我管理的影响也提供了进一步的研究机会。目前也缺乏评估同伴教育者积极参与卫生服务提供和组织模式的研究。