Cottrell Elizabeth, Cox Tracey, O'Connell Phil, Chambers Ruth
Trentham Mews Medical Centre, Staffordshire, UK.
NHS Stoke-on-Trent Clinical Commissioning Group, Stoke-on-Trent, UK.
BMJ Open. 2015 Mar 20;5(3):e007270. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2014-007270.
To establish patient and professional user satisfaction with the Advice & Interactive Messaging (AIM) for Health programme delivered using a mobile phone-based, simple telehealth intervention, 'Florence'.
A service evaluation using data extracted from Florence and from a professional user electronic survey.
425 primary care practices across 31 Clinical Commissioning Groups in England.
3381 patients registered on 1 of 10 AIM protocols between March 2013 and January 2014 and 77 professional users.
The AIM programme offered 10 clinical protocols, in three broad groups: (1) hypertension diagnosis/monitoring, (2) medication reminders and (3) smoking cessation. Florence sent patients prompts to submit clinical information, educational messages and user satisfaction questions. Patient responses were reviewed by their primary healthcare providers.
Patients and professional user experiences of using AIM, and within this, Florence.
Patient activity using Florence was generally good at month 1 for the hypertension protocols (71-80%), but reduced over 2-3 months (31-60%). For the other protocols, patient activity was 0-39% at 3 months. Minimum target days of texting were met for half the hypertension protocols. 1707/2304 (74%) patients sent evaluative texts responded at least once. Among responders, agreement with the adapted friends and family statement generally exceeded preproject aspirations. Professional responders were generally positive or equivocal about the programme.
Satisfaction with AIM appeared optimal when patients were carefully selected for the protocol; professional users were familiar with the system, the programme addressed a problem with the previous service delivery that was identified by users and users took an active approach to achieve clinical goals. However, there was a significant decrease in patients' use of Florence over time. Future applications may be optimised by identifying and addressing reasons for the waning use of the service and enhancing support during implementation of the service.
通过使用基于手机的简单远程医疗干预措施“弗洛伦斯”,对健康咨询与互动消息(AIM)计划的患者和专业用户满意度进行评估。
利用从“弗洛伦斯”及专业用户电子调查问卷中提取的数据进行服务评估。
英格兰31个临床委托小组中的425家初级保健机构。
2013年3月至2014年1月期间,在10种AIM方案中的1种上注册的3381名患者以及77名专业用户。
AIM计划提供10种临床方案,分为三大类:(1)高血压诊断/监测,(2)用药提醒,(3)戒烟。“弗洛伦斯”向患者发送提示,要求其提交临床信息、教育信息及用户满意度问题。患者的回复由其初级医疗保健提供者进行审核。
患者和专业用户使用AIM以及在此过程中使用“弗洛伦斯”的体验。
对于高血压方案,患者在第1个月使用“弗洛伦斯”的情况总体良好(71%-80%),但在2至3个月内有所下降(31%-60%)。对于其他方案,3个月时患者的使用率为0%-39%。一半的高血压方案达到了最低短信发送天数目标。在2304名发送评估短信的患者中,1707名(74%)至少回复了一次。在回复者中,对改编后的朋友和家人声明的认同度普遍超过了项目实施前的预期。专业回复者对该计划总体持积极或模棱两可的态度。
当为方案精心挑选患者时,对AIM的满意度似乎最佳;专业用户熟悉该系统,该计划解决了用户指出的先前服务提供方面的问题,且用户积极采取措施实现临床目标。然而,随着时间的推移,患者对“弗洛伦斯”的使用显著减少。未来的应用可通过找出并解决服务使用减少的原因以及在服务实施过程中加强支持来进行优化。