Aebi M, Etter C, Coscia M
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Berne, Inselspital, Switzerland.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 1989 Oct;14(10):1065-70. doi: 10.1097/00007632-198910000-00007.
Seventeen cases of Anderson and D'Alonzo Type II and "shallow" Type III fractures of the odontoid, treated by anterior screw fixation, were reviewed and compared with previously published series of fractures treated nonoperatively, treated with posterior C1-C2 arthrodeses, and with anterior screw fixation series. Although the nonunion rate (12%) and major complication rate (24%) in the present series were higher than those previously reported, the combined rates of all anterior screw fixation series were comparable to those of posterior C1-C2 arthrodesis studies. Three of the complications presented occurred in cases that in retrospect were inappropriate for the use of this technique. These included a verified nonunion and 2 individuals with markedly osteoporotic bone and unfavorable fracture type. Because of the difficulty involved in mastering anterior screw fixation of the dens, its use should be limited to experienced spine surgeons with the appropriate surgical facilities.
回顾了17例采用前路螺钉固定治疗的Anderson和D’Alonzo II型及“浅”III型齿状突骨折病例,并与先前发表的非手术治疗、后路C1-C2关节融合术治疗以及前路螺钉固定治疗的骨折系列进行了比较。尽管本系列中的不愈合率(12%)和主要并发症发生率(24%)高于先前报道,但所有前路螺钉固定系列的综合发生率与后路C1-C2关节融合术研究的发生率相当。出现的3例并发症发生在回顾时不适合使用该技术的病例中。这些包括1例经证实的不愈合以及2例骨质疏松明显且骨折类型不佳的患者。由于掌握齿状突前路螺钉固定存在困难,其应用应限于具备适当手术设施的经验丰富的脊柱外科医生。