Zhang Wen-yuan, Li Ying-ran, Li Yun-jing, Li Xue-qin, Zhao Wei-guo, Lu Rong-zhi
Department of Pharmacy, Zhongshan Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University, Zhongshan, 528403, China.
School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, 510006, China.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2015 Mar 13;15:98. doi: 10.1186/s12913-015-0778-3.
An essential medicine (EM) system has been implemented in China to reduce patients' financial burden and to make the use of drugs more rational. This study aims to evaluate the current state of the EM system in Guangdong Province.
We conducted surveys in 21 cities in 2012, covering 98 medical institutions, 1,509 doctors, 17 medicine manufacturers, and 17 distribution companies. We also reviewed outpatient prescriptions (n = 9,941) for treating hypertension, diabetes, bacterial infections and gout to measure the rational use of drugs in secondary and tertiary (upper-level) hospitals.
The percentage of non-priority EM use ranged from 8.1% to 10.7% in upper-level hospitals, and this non-priority use significantly increased prescription drug costs. Other types of inappropriate medicine use were found more frequently in treating bacterial infections (7.4%) than in treating hypertension (1.6%), diabetes (1.3%) and gout (1.7%). Tertiary hospitals prescribed fewer EMs than secondary hospitals; moreover, tertiary hospitals had higher prescription drug costs. The zero mark-up policy decreased prescription drug costs in secondary hospitals. The survey revealed that forced full-prescription EM use might lead to fewer patient visits to primary hospitals. Manufacturers had halted the production of four (1, 23) types of EMs at the time of the survey.
Encouraging the priority use of EMs and implementation of the zero mark-up policy were effective in curtailing prescription medicine costs in upper-level hospitals. Further work should focus on the following: creating guidelines to enhance rational prescription behavior, establishing policies to support EM use in upper-level hospitals and improving the bidding system to ensure a steady supply of the lowest-priced generic drugs.
中国已实施基本药物(EM)制度,以减轻患者经济负担并使药物使用更加合理。本研究旨在评估广东省EM制度的现状。
2012年我们在21个城市开展了调查,涵盖98家医疗机构、1509名医生、17家药品生产企业和17家配送公司。我们还审查了治疗高血压、糖尿病、细菌感染和痛风的门诊处方(n = 9941),以衡量二级和三级(上级)医院药物的合理使用情况。
上级医院非优先使用EM的比例在8.1%至10.7%之间,这种非优先使用显著增加了处方药费用。在治疗细菌感染时发现的其他类型的不当用药情况(7.4%)比治疗高血压(1.6%)、糖尿病(1.3%)和痛风(1.7%)时更频繁。三级医院开具的EM比二级医院少;此外,三级医院的处方药费用更高。零加价政策降低了二级医院的处方药费用。调查显示,强制全额处方使用EM可能导致到基层医院就诊的患者减少。在调查时,生产企业已停止生产四种(1, 23)类型的EM。
鼓励优先使用EM和实施零加价政策在降低上级医院处方药费用方面是有效的。进一步的工作应集中在以下方面:制定指南以增强合理处方行为,制定支持上级医院使用EM的政策,以及改进招标系统以确保低价通用药物的稳定供应。