Sears David, Mpimbaza Arthur, Kigozi Ruth, Sserwanga Asadu, Chang Michelle A, Kapella Bryan K, Yoon Steven, Kamya Moses R, Dorsey Grant, Ruel Theodore
Department of Medicine, San Francisco General Hospital, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States of America.
Uganda Malaria Surveillance Project, Kampala, Uganda; Child Health & Development Centre, Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda.
PLoS One. 2015 May 19;10(5):e0127192. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0127192. eCollection 2015.
A better understanding of case management practices is required to improve inpatient pediatric care in resource-limited settings. Here we utilize data from a unique health facility-based surveillance system at six Ugandan hospitals to evaluate the quality of pediatric case management and the factors associated with appropriate care.
All children up to the age of 14 years admitted to six district or regional hospitals over 15 months were included in the study. Four case management categories were defined for analysis: suspected malaria, selected illnesses requiring antibiotics, suspected anemia, and diarrhea. The quality of case management for each category was determined by comparing recorded treatments with evidence-based best practices as defined in national guidelines. Associations between variables of interest and the receipt of appropriate case management were estimated using multivariable logistic regression.
A total of 30,351 admissions were screened for inclusion in the analysis. Ninety-two percent of children met criteria for suspected malaria and 81% received appropriate case management. Thirty-two percent of children had selected illnesses requiring antibiotics and 89% received appropriate antibiotics. Thirty percent of children met criteria for suspected anemia and 38% received appropriate case management. Twelve percent of children had diarrhea and 18% received appropriate case management. Multivariable logistic regression revealed large differences in the quality of care between health facilities. There was also a strong association between a positive malaria diagnostic test result and the odds of receiving appropriate case management for comorbid non-malarial illnesses - children with a positive malaria test were more likely to receive appropriate care for anemia and less likely for illnesses requiring antibiotics and diarrhea.
Appropriate management of suspected anemia and diarrhea occurred infrequently. Pediatric quality improvement initiatives should target deficiencies in care unique to each health facility, and interventions should focus on the simultaneous management of multiple diagnoses.
为改善资源有限环境下的儿科住院治疗,需要更好地了解病例管理实践。在此,我们利用乌干达六家医院基于独特卫生设施的监测系统的数据,评估儿科病例管理的质量以及与适当治疗相关的因素。
研究纳入了15个月内入住六家地区或区域医院的所有14岁以下儿童。定义了四个病例管理类别进行分析:疑似疟疾、需要抗生素治疗的特定疾病、疑似贫血和腹泻。通过将记录的治疗方法与国家指南中定义的循证最佳实践进行比较,确定每个类别的病例管理质量。使用多变量逻辑回归估计感兴趣的变量与接受适当病例管理之间的关联。
共筛选了30351例入院病例纳入分析。92%的儿童符合疑似疟疾标准,81%接受了适当的病例管理。32%的儿童患有需要抗生素治疗的特定疾病,89%接受了适当的抗生素治疗。30%的儿童符合疑似贫血标准,38%接受了适当的病例管理。12%的儿童患有腹泻,18%接受了适当的病例管理。多变量逻辑回归显示,不同卫生设施之间的治疗质量存在很大差异。疟疾诊断检测结果呈阳性与合并非疟疾疾病接受适当病例管理的几率之间也存在很强的关联——疟疾检测呈阳性的儿童更有可能接受适当的贫血治疗,而接受抗生素治疗和腹泻治疗的可能性较小。
对疑似贫血和腹泻的适当管理并不常见。儿科质量改进举措应针对每个卫生设施特有的护理缺陷,干预措施应侧重于同时管理多种诊断。