Cranwell Matthew B, Pearce Bradley, Loveridge Camilla, Hurlbert Anya C
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2015 May;56(5):3171-8. doi: 10.1167/iovs.14-16094.
The Farnsworth-Munsell 100-Hue test (FM100) is a standardized measure of chromatic discrimination, based on colored cap-sorting, which has been widely used in both adults and children. Its dependence on seriation ability raises questions as to its universal suitability and accuracy in assessing purely sensory discrimination. This study investigates how general intellectual ability relates to performance on both the FM100 and a new computer-based chromatic discrimination threshold test, across different age groups in both typical and atypical development.
Participants were divided into two main age groups, children (6-15 years) and young adults (16-25 years), with each group further subdivided into typically developing (TD; three groups; TD 6-7 years, TD 8-9 years, TD Adult) individuals and atypically developing individuals, all but one carrying a diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD; two groups; atypically developing [ATY] child 7-15 years, ASD Adult). General intelligence was measured using the Wechsler Abbreviated Intelligence Scale and Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children. All participants completed the FM100. Both child groups also completed a computer-based chromatic discrimination threshold test, which assessed discrimination along cone-opponent ("red-green," "blue-yellow") and luminance cardinal axes using a controlled staircase procedure.
Farnsworth-Munsell 100-Hue test performance was better in adults than in children. Furthermore, performance significantly positively correlated with nonverbal intelligence quotient (NVIQ) for all child groups and the young adult ASD group. The slope of this relationship was steeper for the ASD than TD groups. Performance on the chromatic discrimination threshold test was not significantly related to any IQ measure. Regression models reveal that chromatic discrimination threshold, although a significant predictor of FM100 performance when used alone, is a weaker predictor than NVIQ used alone or in combination.
The results indicate that FM100 performance is not purely a measure of color discrimination but instead also reflects general nonverbal ability. Other measures of chromatic discrimination ability are therefore required for its accurate assessment, particularly in early or atypical development.
法恩斯沃思 - 芒塞尔100色调测试(FM100)是一种基于彩色帽分类的标准化色觉辨别测量方法,已在成人和儿童中广泛使用。它对序列能力的依赖引发了关于其在评估纯感官辨别方面的普遍适用性和准确性的问题。本研究调查了在典型和非典型发育的不同年龄组中,一般智力能力与FM100测试及一种新的基于计算机的色觉辨别阈值测试表现之间的关系。
参与者分为两个主要年龄组,儿童(6 - 15岁)和青年成人(16 - 25岁),每个组进一步细分为典型发育(TD;三组;TD 6 - 7岁、TD 8 - 9岁、TD成人)个体和非典型发育个体,除一人外均患有自闭症谱系障碍(ASD;两组;非典型发育[ATY]儿童7 - 15岁、ASD成人)。使用韦氏简式智力量表和韦氏儿童智力量表测量一般智力。所有参与者完成FM100测试。两个儿童组还完成了一项基于计算机的色觉辨别阈值测试,该测试使用受控阶梯程序沿着锥体对立轴(“红 - 绿”、“蓝 - 黄”)和亮度主轴评估辨别能力。
法恩斯沃思 - 芒塞尔100色调测试的表现成人优于儿童。此外,所有儿童组和青年成人ASD组的表现与非言语智商(NVIQ)显著正相关。ASD组这种关系的斜率比TD组更陡。色觉辨别阈值测试的表现与任何智商测量均无显著相关性。回归模型显示,色觉辨别阈值虽然单独使用时是FM100表现的显著预测指标,但比单独使用或联合使用的NVIQ预测能力更弱。
结果表明,FM100表现并非纯粹是颜色辨别的测量指标,而是还反映了一般非言语能力。因此,为了准确评估,特别是在早期或非典型发育中,需要其他色觉辨别能力的测量方法。