Forin-Wiart Marie-Amélie, Hubert Pauline, Sirguey Pascal, Poulle Marie-Lazarine
Université de Reims Champagne-Ardenne, SFR Cap Santé, EA3800 PROTAL, Reims, France; Université de Reims Champagne-Ardenne, CERFE, Boult-aux-Bois, France.
Université de Reims Champagne-Ardenne, CERFE, Boult-aux-Bois, France.
PLoS One. 2015 Jun 18;10(6):e0129271. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0129271. eCollection 2015.
Recently developed low-cost Global Positioning System (GPS) data loggers are promising tools for wildlife research because of their affordability for low-budget projects and ability to simultaneously track a greater number of individuals compared with expensive built-in wildlife GPS. However, the reliability of these devices must be carefully examined because they were not developed to track wildlife. This study aimed to assess the performance and accuracy of commercially available GPS data loggers for the first time using the same methods applied to test built-in wildlife GPS. The effects of antenna position, fix interval and habitat on the fix-success rate (FSR) and location error (LE) of CatLog data loggers were investigated in stationary tests, whereas the effects of animal movements on these errors were investigated in motion tests. The units operated well and presented consistent performance and accuracy over time in stationary tests, and the FSR was good for all antenna positions and fix intervals. However, the LE was affected by the GPS antenna and fix interval. Furthermore, completely or partially obstructed habitats reduced the FSR by up to 80% in households and increased the LE. Movement across habitats had no effect on the FSR, whereas forest habitat influenced the LE. Finally, the mean FSR (0.90 ± 0.26) and LE (15.4 ± 10.1 m) values from low-cost GPS data loggers were comparable to those of built-in wildlife GPS collars (71.6% of fixes with LE < 10 m for motion tests), thus confirming their suitability for use in wildlife studies.
最近开发的低成本全球定位系统(GPS)数据记录器是野生动物研究中很有前景的工具,因为它们对于低预算项目来说价格可承受,而且与昂贵的内置野生动物GPS相比,能够同时追踪更多个体。然而,由于这些设备并非专门为追踪野生动物而开发,其可靠性必须仔细检验。本研究旨在首次使用与测试内置野生动物GPS相同的方法,评估市售GPS数据记录器的性能和准确性。在静态测试中,研究了天线位置、定位间隔和栖息地对CatLog数据记录器的定位成功率(FSR)和定位误差(LE)的影响,而在动态测试中,研究了动物移动对这些误差的影响。在静态测试中,这些设备运行良好,且随着时间推移表现出一致的性能和准确性,所有天线位置和定位间隔的FSR都很好。然而,LE受GPS天线和定位间隔的影响。此外,完全或部分受阻的栖息地使家庭环境中的FSR降低了80%,并增加了LE。跨栖息地移动对FSR没有影响,而森林栖息地影响LE。最后,低成本GPS数据记录器的平均FSR(0.90±0.26)和LE(15.4±10.1米)值与内置野生动物GPS项圈相当(动态测试中71.6%的定位LE<10米),从而证实了它们适用于野生动物研究。