Rattan S, Coxon A, Kreitzman S, Lemons A
Howard Foundation Research, Cambridge, UK.
Int J Obes. 1989;13 Suppl 2:189-92.
The challenge to maintain lost weight is particularly relevant for advocates of VLCD, since these induce a high rate of weight loss. It has been argued that excessive lean body mass is lost with very restricted energy intake regimens which compromises metabolic rate and sabotages weight maintenance. Thirty-nine subjects who had lost an average of 12.3 +/- 2 kg during an 8-week VLCD trial were transferred immediately to a 1500 kcal per day maintenance formula which included solid foods. RMR was determined at four intervals: (1) before dieting; (2) after 2 weeks of VLCD; (3) end of 8 weeks dieting; (4) end of 8 weeks maintenance period. It was observed that the metabolic rate dropped to 86 per cent of original by the end of the 8 weeks of VLCD. Metabolic rate recovered to 93 per cent of prediet values by the end of 8 weeks of weight maintenance on 1500 kcal/day. Following an average 2 kg weight regain within the first week of maintenance, there was no further weight regain. VLCD did not produce losses of RMR beyond that expected from the loss of weight. No difficulty was observed in maintaining weight for 8 weeks on 1500 kcal/day.
对于极低热量饮食(VLCD)的倡导者来说,维持体重减轻的挑战尤为突出,因为这些饮食方式会导致很高的体重减轻率。有人认为,在能量摄入非常受限的饮食方案中,过多的瘦体重会流失,这会损害代谢率并破坏体重维持。39名在为期8周的VLCD试验中平均减重12.3±2千克的受试者,立即被转移到每天1500千卡的维持配方饮食中,该饮食包括固体食物。在四个时间点测定静息代谢率(RMR):(1)节食前;(2)VLCD 2周后;(3)8周节食结束时;(4)8周维持期结束时。观察到在8周的VLCD结束时,代谢率降至原来的86%。在每天1500千卡的体重维持8周结束时,代谢率恢复到节食前值的93%。在维持的第一周内平均体重反弹2千克后,体重没有进一步反弹。VLCD导致的RMR降低幅度并未超过因体重减轻而预期的幅度。在每天1500千卡的情况下维持8周体重未观察到困难。