Rooney James P K, Tobin Katy, Crampsie Arlene, Vajda Alice, Heverin Mark, McLaughlin Russell, Staines Anthony, Hardiman Orla
Academic Unit of Neurology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College, Dublin 2, Ireland.
School of Geography, Planning and Environmental Policy, University College Dublin Belfield, Dublin, Ireland.
Environ Res. 2015 Oct;142:141-7. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2015.06.024. Epub 2015 Jul 2.
Evidence of an association between areal ALS risk and population density has been previously reported. We aim to examine ALS spatial incidence in Ireland using small areas, to compare this analysis with our previous analysis of larger areas and to examine the associations between population density, social deprivation and ALS incidence.
Residential area social deprivation has not been previously investigated as a risk factor for ALS. Using the Irish ALS register, we included all cases of ALS diagnosed in Ireland from 1995-2013. 2006 census data was used to calculate age and sex standardised expected cases per small area. Social deprivation was assessed using the pobalHP deprivation index. Bayesian smoothing was used to calculate small area relative risk for ALS, whilst cluster analysis was performed using SaTScan. The effects of population density and social deprivation were tested in two ways: (1) as covariates in the Bayesian spatial model; (2) via post-Bayesian regression.
1701 cases were included. Bayesian smoothed maps of relative risk at small area resolution matched closely to our previous analysis at a larger area resolution. Cluster analysis identified two areas of significant low risk. These areas did not correlate with population density or social deprivation indices.
Two areas showing low frequency of ALS have been identified in the Republic of Ireland. These areas do not correlate with population density or residential area social deprivation, indicating that other reasons, such as genetic admixture may account for the observed findings.
此前已有报道称,地区性肌萎缩侧索硬化症(ALS)风险与人口密度之间存在关联。我们旨在利用小区域来研究爱尔兰的ALS空间发病率,将此分析与我们之前对大区域的分析进行比较,并研究人口密度、社会剥夺与ALS发病率之间的关联。
此前尚未将居住区社会剥夺作为ALS的风险因素进行研究。利用爱尔兰ALS登记册,我们纳入了1995年至2013年在爱尔兰诊断出的所有ALS病例。使用2006年人口普查数据计算每个小区域按年龄和性别标准化的预期病例数。使用pobalHP剥夺指数评估社会剥夺情况。采用贝叶斯平滑法计算ALS的小区域相对风险,同时使用SaTScan进行聚类分析。从两个方面测试了人口密度和社会剥夺的影响:(1)作为贝叶斯空间模型中的协变量;(2)通过贝叶斯后回归分析。
共纳入1701例病例。小区域分辨率下的贝叶斯平滑相对风险图与我们之前大区域分辨率下的分析结果密切匹配。聚类分析确定了两个显著低风险区域。这些区域与人口密度或社会剥夺指数无关。
在爱尔兰共和国已确定了两个ALS发病率较低的区域。这些区域与人口密度或居住区社会剥夺无关,这表明其他原因,如基因混合,可能是观察结果的原因。