Gratz Kim L, Chapman Alexander L, Dixon-Gordon Katherine L, Tull Matthew T
Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, University of Mississippi Medical Center.
Department of Psychology, Simon Fraser University.
Personal Disord. 2016 Jan;7(1):91-102. doi: 10.1037/per0000138. Epub 2015 Jul 6.
Despite the growing consensus that negative reinforcement in the form of emotional relief plays a key role in the maintenance of deliberate self-harm (DSH), most of the research in this area has relied exclusively on self-report measures of the perceived motives for and emotional consequences of DSH. Thus, the primary aim of this study was to extend extant research on the role of emotional relief in DSH by examining the strength of the association of DSH with emotional relief using a novel version of the Implicit Association Test (IAT). The strength of the DSH-relief association among both participants with (vs. without) DSH and self-harming participants with (vs. without) BPD, as well as its associations with relevant clinical constructs (including DSH characteristics, self-reported motives for DSH, BPD pathology, and emotion dysregulation and avoidance) were examined in a community sample of young adults (113 with recent recurrent DSH; 135 without DSH). As hypothesized, results revealed stronger associations between DSH and relief among participants with versus without DSH, as well as among DSH participants with versus without BPD. Moreover, the strength of the DSH-relief association was positively associated with DSH frequency and versatility (both lifetime and at 6-month follow-up), BPD pathology, emotion dysregulation, experiential avoidance, and self-reported emotion relief motives for DSH. Findings provide support for theories emphasizing the role of emotional relief in DSH (particularly among individuals with BPD), as well as the construct validity, predictive utility, and incremental validity (relative to self-reported emotion relief motives) of this IAT.
尽管越来越多的人达成共识,即情绪缓解形式的负强化在故意自我伤害(DSH)的维持中起关键作用,但该领域的大多数研究仅依赖于对DSH的感知动机和情绪后果的自我报告测量。因此,本研究的主要目的是通过使用一种新型的内隐联想测验(IAT)来检验DSH与情绪缓解之间关联的强度,从而扩展关于情绪缓解在DSH中作用的现有研究。在一个年轻成年人社区样本(113名近期有复发性DSH的参与者;135名无DSH的参与者)中,研究了有(与无)DSH的参与者以及有(与无)边缘型人格障碍(BPD)的自我伤害参与者之间DSH - 缓解关联的强度,以及它与相关临床构念(包括DSH特征、自我报告的DSH动机、BPD病理学、情绪失调和回避)的关联。正如所假设的,结果显示有DSH与无DSH的参与者之间,以及有BPD与无BPD的DSH参与者之间,DSH与缓解之间的关联更强。此外,DSH - 缓解关联的强度与DSH频率和多样性(终身和6个月随访时)、BPD病理学、情绪失调、经验回避以及自我报告的DSH情绪缓解动机呈正相关。研究结果为强调情绪缓解在DSH中作用的理论(特别是在患有BPD的个体中)提供了支持,同时也为该IAT的结构效度、预测效用和增量效度(相对于自我报告的情绪缓解动机)提供了支持。