Obrzut J E, Conrad P F, Boliek C A
Program in Educational Psychology, College of Education, University of Arizona, Tucson 85721.
Neuropsychologia. 1989;27(11-12):1357-71. doi: 10.1016/0028-3932(89)90130-9.
Cerebral lateralization of left- and right-handed good readers and left- and right-handed reading disabled was examined with a sample of 60 children who ranged in age from 7-13 years via a dichotic selective attention task (free recall, directed left, directed right) using consonant-vowel (CV) and tonal stimuli. Several ANOVAs were conducted to evaluate gender, reader group, handedness, and stimuli effects of left- and right-ear reports across dichotic conditions. Results indicated males outperformed females across stimuli and conditions regardless of handedness and all subjects recalled more tonal stimuli than CV stimuli. More importantly, the expected REA (left hemisphere processing) was found for CV stimuli only by right-handed good readers across all three dichotic conditions. The left-handed good readers and left-handed reading-disabled children were left ear (LE) dominant in free recall and in the directed left condition, but were right ear (RE) dominant in the directed right condition. Conversely, right-handed reading-disabled children produced a REA during free recall and directed right conditions, but were LE dominant in the directed left condition. In contrast, a significant LEA (right hemisphere processing) was found for tonal stimuli across all dichotic conditions for all four groups. These findings lend support to the hypothesis that attentional factors have a greater influence on auditory processing of verbal than nonverbal stimuli for various groups of children and also suggest reversed or bilateralized processing abilities for language in strongly left-handed children with sinistral relatives.
通过一项双耳选择性注意任务(自由回忆、向左定向、向右定向),使用辅音-元音(CV)和声调刺激,对60名年龄在7至13岁之间的儿童样本进行了研究,以考察左利手和右利手的优秀阅读者以及左利手和右利手的阅读障碍者的大脑半球偏侧化情况。进行了多项方差分析,以评估性别、阅读者组、利手以及双耳条件下左耳和右耳报告的刺激效应。结果表明,无论利手情况如何,在所有刺激和条件下男性的表现均优于女性,并且所有受试者对声调刺激的回忆都多于CV刺激。更重要的是,只有右利手的优秀阅读者在所有三种双耳条件下对CV刺激表现出预期的右耳优势(左半球加工)。左利手的优秀阅读者和左利手的阅读障碍儿童在自由回忆和向左定向条件下以左耳(LE)为主,但在向右定向条件下以右耳(RE)为主。相反,右利手的阅读障碍儿童在自由回忆和向右定向条件下表现出右耳优势,但在向左定向条件下以左耳为主。相比之下,所有四组在所有双耳条件下对声调刺激均表现出显著的左耳优势(右半球加工)。这些发现支持了这样一种假设,即对于不同组的儿童,注意因素对言语听觉加工的影响比对非言语刺激的影响更大,并且还表明有左利手亲属的强左利手儿童在语言加工能力上存在反转或双侧化现象。