Khatun Fatema, Heywood Anita E, Ray Pradeep K, Hanifi S M A, Bhuiya Abbas, Liaw Siaw-Teng
School of Public Health and Community Medicine, UNSW Australia, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia; Asia-Pacific ubiquitous Healthcare Research Centre, School of Information Systems, Technology and Management, Australian School of Business, UNSW Australia, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia; International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh (icddr,b), 68 Shaheed Tajuddin Ahmed Sarani, Mohakhali, Dhaka 1212, Bangladesh.
School of Public Health and Community Medicine, UNSW Australia, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia.
Int J Med Inform. 2015 Oct;84(10):847-56. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2015.06.008. Epub 2015 Jul 2.
Evidence in favor of mHealth for healthcare delivery in settings where trained health workforce is limited or unavailable is accumulating. With rapid growth in access to mobile phones and an acute shortage of health workforce in Bangladesh, mHealth initiatives are increasing with more than 20 current initiatives in place. "Readiness" is a crucial prerequisite to the successful implementation of telehealth programs. However, systematic assessment of the community readiness for mHealth-based services in the country is lacking. We report on a recent study describing the influence of community readiness for mHealth of a rural Bangladesh community.
A conceptual framework for mHealth readiness was developed, which included three categories: technological, motivational and resource readiness. This guided the questionnaire development for the survey conducted in the Chakaria sub-district of Bangladesh from November 2012 to April 2013. Multivariate logistic regression was used to examine ownership of mobile phones, use of the technology, and knowledge regarding awareness of mHealth services as predictors of the community readiness to adopt mHealth.
A total of 4915 randomly selected household members aged 18 years and over completed the survey. The data explained the sub-categories of the readiness dimensions. In terms of access, 45% of respondents owned a mobile phone with ownership higher among males, younger participants and those in the highest socioeconomic quintiles. Results related to technological readiness showed that among mobile phone owners, 50% were aware of SMS but only sending and receiving SMS. Only 37% generally read the received SMS. Only 5% of respondents used the internet capabilities on their phone and 25% used voice messages. The majority (73%) of the participants were interested in joining mHealth programs in the future. Multivariate analysis showed that ownership of a mobile phone (aOR 1.3, 95% CI 1.1-1.5), younger age (aOR 2.6, 95% CI 2.1-3.3), males (aOR 1.8, 95% CI 1.6-2.1), educated respondents (11 years or more education) (aOR 11.1, 95% CI 6.2-19.2) and those belonging to the highest socio-economic group (aOR 3.7, 95% CI 2.9-4.7) were significantly independently associated with knowledge regarding awareness of current mHealth services.
We developed a conceptual framework to assess community readiness for mHealth. We described three high level dimensions of readiness and have partially tested the conceptual framework in a rural sub-district in Bangladesh. We found that the community has some technological readiness but inequity was observed for human resource readiness and technological capabilities. The study population is motivated to use mHealth. Our conceptual framework is a promising tool to assist policy-makers in planning and implementing mHealth programs.
在受过培训的卫生人力有限或无法获得的环境中,支持移动医疗用于医疗服务提供的证据正在不断积累。随着孟加拉国手机普及率的迅速增长以及卫生人力的严重短缺,移动医疗倡议不断增加,目前已有20多项倡议正在实施。“准备情况”是远程医疗项目成功实施的关键先决条件。然而,该国缺乏对社区对基于移动医疗的服务的准备情况的系统评估。我们报告了一项近期研究,该研究描述了孟加拉国一个农村社区对移动医疗的社区准备情况的影响。
制定了一个移动医疗准备情况的概念框架,其中包括三个类别:技术准备、动机准备和资源准备。这指导了2012年11月至2013年4月在孟加拉国查卡里亚分区进行的调查的问卷开发。使用多变量逻辑回归来检验手机拥有情况、技术使用情况以及关于移动医疗服务知晓度的知识,以此作为社区采用移动医疗的准备情况的预测因素。
共有4915名随机抽取的18岁及以上家庭成员完成了调查。数据解释了准备情况维度的子类别。在获取方面,45%的受访者拥有手机,男性、年轻参与者以及社会经济最高五分位数人群的手机拥有率更高。与技术准备相关的结果表明,在手机拥有者中,50%知晓短信但仅用于收发短信。只有37%的人通常会阅读收到的短信。只有5%的受访者使用手机的互联网功能,25%的人使用语音消息。大多数(73%)参与者对未来加入移动医疗项目感兴趣。多变量分析表明,拥有手机(调整后比值比1.3,95%置信区间1.1 - 1.5)、年龄较小(调整后比值比2.6,95%置信区间2.1 - 3.3)、男性(调整后比值比1.8,95%置信区间1.6 - 2.1)、受过教育的受访者(受教育11年或以上)(调整后比值比11.1,95%置信区间6.2 - 19.2)以及属于社会经济最高组别的人群(调整后比值比3.7,95%置信区间2.9 - 4.7)与对当前移动医疗服务知晓度的知识显著独立相关。
我们开发了一个概念框架来评估社区对移动医疗的准备情况。我们描述了准备情况的三个高层次维度,并在孟加拉国的一个农村分区对该概念框架进行了部分测试。我们发现社区具备一定的技术准备,但在人力资源准备和技术能力方面存在不平等现象。研究人群有使用移动医疗的动机。我们的概念框架是协助政策制定者规划和实施移动医疗项目的一个有前景的工具。