Schaible Lonnie M, Altheimer Irshad
University of Colorado Denver, USA
Rochester Institute of Technology, NY, USA.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2016 Jun;60(8):936-63. doi: 10.1177/0306624X15595420. Epub 2015 Jul 27.
Merton's "Social Structure and Anomie" seeks to explain how "socio-cultural" influences exert "definite pressures" to engage in non-conformity. Despite having a significant influence, few studies have assessed the degree to which Merton's propositions explain cross-national variation in levels of crime. Using data on national levels of homicide, data from the World Values Survey, and other structural controls, the present study assesses the degree to which deinstitutionalization, demoralization, and blocked opportunity interact to explain crime cross-nationally. Results provide a high degree of support for Merton's assertion that societal types characterized by relatively high levels of materialism and/or demoralization or deinstitutionalization suffer from higher levels of homicide. However, there is less support for Merton's assertion that inequality interacts with various societal patterns of means/ends integration in a meaningful way. Findings and implications for the utility of classical anomie as a general macro-level theory are discussed.
默顿的《社会结构与失范》试图解释“社会文化”影响如何施加“明确压力”促使人们做出不符合规范的行为。尽管具有重大影响,但很少有研究评估默顿的命题在多大程度上能够解释跨国犯罪水平的差异。本研究利用各国凶杀案水平的数据、世界价值观调查的数据以及其他结构控制变量,评估了去制度化、道德沦丧和机会受阻相互作用在跨国层面上对犯罪的解释程度。结果高度支持默顿的论断,即具有相对较高物质主义水平和/或道德沦丧或去制度化特征的社会类型,凶杀案发生率更高。然而,对于默顿关于不平等以有意义的方式与各种手段/目的整合的社会模式相互作用的论断,支持较少。本文讨论了这些发现以及经典失范理论作为一种一般宏观层面理论的效用的相关启示。