Hays J R
Psychol Rep. 1989 Dec;65(3 Pt 2):1211-5. doi: 10.2466/pr0.1989.65.3f.1211.
The United States Supreme Court in 1979 set the standard for involuntary commitment. This decision, styled Addington v Texas, raised the burden of proof required to commit persons from the usual civil burden of proof of "preponderance of the evidence" to "clear and convincing" evidence. There was no reduction in the rates of commitment as a result of the decision. The proportion of patients committed in Texas grew in almost linear fashion during the years 1972-1986. Various economic, sociological, and treatment factors may have more influence on commitment of patients than does a court decision.
1979年,美国最高法院设定了非自愿住院治疗的标准。这一判决,即“阿丁顿诉得克萨斯州案”,将判定某人住院治疗所需的举证责任从通常的民事举证责任“优势证据”提高到“清晰且有说服力”的证据。该判决并未导致住院率下降。在1972年至1986年期间,得克萨斯州被强制住院的患者比例几乎呈线性增长。与法院判决相比,各种经济、社会和治疗因素可能对患者的住院治疗有更大影响。