Mabuza Langalibalele H, Omole Olufemi B, Govender Indiran, Ndimande John V
Department of Family Medicine and Primary Health Care, University of Limpopo (Medunsa Campus).
Afr J Prim Health Care Fam Med. 2014 Mar 10;6(1):E1-8. doi: 10.4102/phcfm.v6i1.576.
Healthcare practitioners should provide patients with information regarding their clinical conditions. Patients should also feel free to seek clarity on information provided. However, not all patients seek this clarity.
To explore the reasons inpatients gave for not seeking clarity on information that was received but not understood.
This was a qualitative arm of a larger study, titled 'Are inpatients aware of the admission reasons and management plans of their clinical conditions? A survey at a tertiary hospital in South Africa', conducted in 2010. Of the 264 inpatients who participated in the larger study, we extracted the unstructured responses from those participants (n = 152) who had indicated in the questionnaire that there was information they had not understood during their encounter with healthcare practitioners, but that they had nonetheless not sought clarity.Data were analysed thematically.
Themes that emerged were that inpatients did not ask for clarity as they perceived healthcare practitioners to be 'too busy', aloof, non-communicators and sometimes uncertain about patients' conditions. Some inpatients had unquestioning trust in healthcare practitioners,whilst others had experiences of bad treatment. Inpatients had poor self-esteem, incapacitating clinical conditions, fear of bad news and prior knowledge of their clinical conditions. Some inpatients stated that they had no reason for not seeking clarity.
The reasons for not seeking clarity were based on patients' experiences with the healthcare practitioners and their perceptions of the latter and of themselves. A programme should be developed in order to educate inpatients on effective communication with their healthcare practitioners.
医疗从业者应向患者提供有关其临床状况的信息。患者也应能够自由地就所提供的信息寻求澄清。然而,并非所有患者都会寻求这种澄清。
探讨住院患者对于已收到但未理解的信息不寻求澄清的原因。
这是一项更大规模研究的定性部分,该研究名为“住院患者是否了解其临床状况的入院原因和管理计划?南非一家三级医院的调查”,于2010年进行。在参与更大规模研究的264名住院患者中,我们从那些在问卷中表明在与医疗从业者接触过程中有未理解的信息,但却未寻求澄清的参与者(n = 152)中提取了非结构化回复。对数据进行了主题分析。
出现的主题包括,住院患者不要求澄清是因为他们认为医疗从业者“太忙”、冷漠、不善沟通,有时对患者的病情也不确定。一些住院患者对医疗从业者毫无质疑地信任,而另一些患者则有过糟糕治疗的经历。住院患者自尊心低、临床状况使他们丧失能力、害怕坏消息以及对自己的临床状况有先入之见。一些住院患者表示他们没有不寻求澄清的理由。
不寻求澄清的原因基于患者与医疗从业者的经历以及他们对医疗从业者和自身的看法。应该制定一个项目,以便对住院患者进行与医疗从业者有效沟通方面的教育。