Yarris Lalena M, Juve Amy Miller, Artino Anthony R, Sullivan Gail M, Rougas Steven, Joyce Barbara, Eva Kevin
J Grad Med Educ. 2014 Sep;6(3):430-6. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-14-00340.1.
To further evolve in an evidence-based fashion, medical education needs to develop and evaluate new practices for teaching, learning, and assessment. However, educators face barriers in designing, conducting, and publishing education research.
To explore the barriers medical educators face in formulating, conducting, and publishing high-quality medical education research, and to identify strategies for overcoming them.
A consensus workshop was held November 5, 2013, at the Association of American Medical Colleges annual meeting. A working group of education research experts and educators completed a preconference literature review focusing on barriers to education research. During the workshop, consensus-based and small group techniques were used to refine the broad themes into content categories. Attendees then ranked the most important barriers and strategies for overcoming them with the highest potential impact.
Barriers participants faced in conducting quality education research included lack of (1) expertise, (2) time, (3) funding, (4) mentorship, and (5) reward. The strategy considered most effective in overcoming these barriers involved building communities of education researchers for collaboration and networking, and advocating for education researchers' interests. Other suggestions included trying to secure increased funding opportunities, developing mentoring programs, and encouraging mechanisms to ensure protected time.
Barriers to education research productivity clearly exist. Many appear to result from feelings of isolation that may be overcome with systemic efforts to develop and enable communities of practice across institutions. Finally, the theme of "reward" is novel and complex and may have implications for education research productivity.
为了以循证的方式进一步发展,医学教育需要开发和评估教学与评估的新实践。然而,教育工作者在设计、开展和发表教育研究方面面临障碍。
探讨医学教育工作者在制定、开展和发表高质量医学教育研究时所面临的障碍,并确定克服这些障碍的策略。
2013年11月5日在美国医学院协会年会上举行了一次共识研讨会。一个由教育研究专家和教育工作者组成的工作组完成了会前文献综述,重点关注教育研究的障碍。在研讨会上,采用基于共识的方法和小组讨论技术,将宽泛的主题细化为内容类别。与会者随后对最重要的障碍以及具有最高潜在影响力的克服这些障碍的策略进行了排序。
参与者在开展高质量教育研究时面临的障碍包括缺乏(1)专业知识、(2)时间、(3)资金、(4)指导以及(5)奖励。被认为最有效地克服这些障碍的策略包括建立教育研究人员社区以促进合作和建立联系,并倡导教育研究人员的利益。其他建议包括努力争取更多的资金机会、制定指导计划以及鼓励确保有受保护时间的机制。
教育研究生产力的障碍显然存在。许多障碍似乎源于孤立感,通过跨机构系统性地努力发展和建立实践社区可能会克服这种感觉。最后,“奖励”这一主题新颖且复杂,可能对教育研究生产力有影响。