van Abswoude Femke, Santos-Vieira Beatriz, van der Kamp John, Steenbergen Bert
Behavioural Science Institute, Radboud University Nijmegen, Montessorilaan 3, PO Box 9104, 6500 HE Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Department of Physiotherapy, Neuropediatrics Section, Federal University of São Carlos, Rod. Washington Luis, km 235, 13565-905 São Carlos, SP, Brazil.
Res Dev Disabil. 2015 Oct-Nov;45-46:353-64. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2015.08.008. Epub 2015 Aug 27.
The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of errors during practice on motor skill learning in young individuals with cerebral palsy (CP). Minimizing errors has been validated in typically developing children and children with intellectual disabilities as a method for implicit learning, because it reduces working memory involvement during learning. The present study assessed whether a practice protocol that aims at minimizing errors can induce implicit learning in young individuals with CP as well. Accordingly, we hypothesized that reducing errors during practice would lead to enhanced learning and a decrease in the dependency of performance on working memory. Young individuals with CP practiced an aiming task following either an error-minimizing (N=20) or an error-strewn (N=18) practice protocol. Aiming accuracy was assessed in pre-, post- and retention test. Dual task performance was assessed to establish dependency on working memory. The two practice protocols did not invoke different amounts or types of learning in the participants with CP. Yet, participants improved aiming accuracy and showed stable motor performance after learning, irrespective of the protocol they followed. Across groups the number of errors made during practice was related to the amount of learning, and the degree of conscious monitoring of the movement. Only participants with relatively good working memory capacity and a poor initial performance showed a rudimentary form of (most likely, explicit) learning. These new findings on the effect of the amount of practice errors on motor learning in children of CP are important for designing interventions for children and adolescents with CP.
本研究的目的是调查练习过程中的错误对患有脑瘫(CP)的年轻人运动技能学习的影响。在正常发育儿童和智障儿童中,将错误最小化已被验证为一种内隐学习方法,因为它减少了学习过程中工作记忆的参与。本研究还评估了旨在最小化错误的练习方案是否也能在患有CP的年轻人中诱导内隐学习。因此,我们假设在练习过程中减少错误将导致学习增强,并且表现对工作记忆的依赖性降低。患有CP的年轻人按照错误最小化(N = 20)或错误频发(N = 18)的练习方案练习一项瞄准任务。在预测试、后测试和保持测试中评估瞄准准确性。评估双重任务表现以确定对工作记忆的依赖性。这两种练习方案在患有CP的参与者中并未引发不同数量或类型的学习。然而,无论遵循哪种方案,参与者在学习后都提高了瞄准准确性并表现出稳定的运动表现。在所有组中,练习过程中犯的错误数量与学习量以及对运动的有意识监测程度有关。只有工作记忆能力相对较好且初始表现较差的参与者表现出一种初步形式的(很可能是外显的)学习。这些关于练习错误量对CP儿童运动学习影响的新发现对于为患有CP的儿童和青少年设计干预措施很重要。