Gelman Susan A, Sánchez Tapia Ingrid, Leslie Sarah-Jane
University of Michigan.
University of Illinois at Chicago.
J Child Lang. 2016 Nov;43(6):1231-44. doi: 10.1017/S0305000915000483. Epub 2015 Sep 3.
Generic language ( Owls eat at night) expresses knowledge about categories and may represent a cognitively default mode of generalization. English-speaking children and adults more accurately recall generic than quantified sentences ( All owls eat at night) and tend to recall quantified sentences as generic. However, generics in English are shorter than quantified sentences, and may be better recalled for this reason. The present study provided a new test of the issue in Spanish, where generics are expressed with an additional linguistic element not found in certain quantified sentences ( Los búhos comen de noche 'Owls eat at night' [generic] vs. Muchos búhos comen de noche 'Many owls eat at night' [quantified]). Both preschoolers and adults recalled generics more accurately than quantified sentences, and quantified sentences were more often recalled as generic than the reverse. These findings provide strong additional evidence for generics as a cognitive default, in an understudied cultural context.
类指性语言(猫头鹰在夜间进食)表达关于类别的知识,并且可能代表一种认知上的默认泛化模式。说英语的儿童和成年人对类指性句子的回忆比对量化句子(所有猫头鹰在夜间进食)更准确,并且倾向于将量化句子回忆为类指性句子。然而,英语中的类指性句子比量化句子短,可能因此更容易被回忆起来。本研究在西班牙语中对该问题进行了一项新测试,在西班牙语中,类指性句子由某些量化句子中不存在的额外语言元素来表达(Los búhos comen de noche,意为“猫头鹰在夜间进食”[类指性],与Muchos búhos comen de noche,意为“许多猫头鹰在夜间进食”[量化])。学龄前儿童和成年人对类指性句子的回忆都比对量化句子更准确,并且量化句子被回忆为类指性句子的情况比相反情况更常见。这些发现为类指性作为一种认知默认提供了有力的额外证据,且是在一个研究较少的文化背景下。