Karim Ali Mehryar, Tamire Addis, Medhanyie Araya Abrha, Betemariam Wuleta
The Last Ten Kilometers Project, JSI Research & Training Institute, Inc., PO Box 13898, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Ministry of Health, Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, PO Box 1234, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2015 Oct 5;15:238. doi: 10.1186/s12884-015-0668-z.
Reducing within-country inequities in the coverage of maternal, newborn, and child health (MNCH) interventions is essential to improving a country's maternal and child health and survival rates. The community-based health extension program (HEP) of Ethiopia, launched in 2003, aims to provide equitable primary health care services. Since 2008 the Last Ten Kilometers Project (L10K) has been supporting the HEP in promoting equitable MNCH interventions in 115 districts covering about 14 million people. We report the inequities in MNCH programmatic indicators in 2008 and in 2010 in the L10K areas, along with changes in equity between the two survey periods, and the implications of these results for the national program.
The study used cross-sectional surveys of 3932 and 3867 women from 129 representative kebeles (communities) conducted in December 2008 and December 2010, respectively. Nineteen HEP outreach activity coverage and MNCH care practice indicators were calculated for each survey period, stratified by the inequity factors considered (i.e. age, education, wealth and distance from the nearest health facility). We calculated relative inequities using concentration indices for each of the indicators and inequity factors. Ninety-five percent confidence intervals and survey design adjusted Wald's statistics were used to assess differentials in equity.
Education and age related inequities in the MNCH indicators were the most prominent (observed for 13 of the 19 outcomes analyzed), followed in order by wealth inequity (observed for eight indicators), and inequity due to distance from the nearest health facility (observed for seven indicators). Age inequities in six of the indicators increased between 2008 and 2010; nevertheless, there was no consistent pattern of changes in inequities during that period. Some related issues such as inequities due to wealth in household visits by the health extension workers and prevalence of modern family household; and inequities due to education in household visits by community health promoters showed improvement.
Addressing these inequities in MNCH interventions by age, education and wealth will contribute significantly toward achieving Ethiopia's maternal health targets for the Millennium Development Goals and beyond. HEP will require more innovative strategies to achieve equitable MNCH services and outcomes and to routinely monitor the effectiveness of those strategies.
减少国内孕产妇、新生儿和儿童健康(MNCH)干预措施覆盖范围方面的不公平现象,对于提高一个国家的孕产妇和儿童健康水平及存活率至关重要。埃塞俄比亚于2003年启动的基于社区的健康推广项目(HEP),旨在提供公平的初级卫生保健服务。自2008年以来,“最后十公里项目”(L10K)一直在支持HEP在115个地区推广公平的MNCH干预措施,这些地区覆盖约1400万人。我们报告了2008年和2010年L10K地区MNCH项目指标的不公平情况,以及两个调查期之间公平性的变化,以及这些结果对国家项目的影响。
该研究分别于2008年12月和2010年12月对来自129个具有代表性的社区(kebeles)的3932名和3867名妇女进行了横断面调查。针对每个调查期,计算了19项HEP外展活动覆盖指标和MNCH护理实践指标,并按所考虑的不公平因素(即年龄、教育程度、财富和距最近卫生设施的距离)进行分层。我们使用集中指数针对每个指标和不公平因素计算了相对不公平性。采用95%置信区间和经调查设计调整的Wald统计量来评估公平性差异。
MNCH指标中与教育和年龄相关的不公平最为突出(在所分析的19项结果中有13项观察到),其次依次是财富不公平(8项指标观察到)以及因距最近卫生设施的距离导致的不公平(7项指标观察到)。2008年至2010年期间,6项指标中的年龄不公平有所增加;然而,在此期间不公平性并没有一致的变化模式。一些相关问题,如健康推广工作者进行家访时因财富导致的不公平以及现代家庭户的患病率;以及社区健康促进者进行家访时因教育导致的不公平有所改善。
解决MNCH干预措施在年龄、教育和财富方面的这些不公平现象,将对实现埃塞俄比亚千年发展目标及以后的孕产妇健康目标做出重大贡献。HEP将需要更具创新性的策略,以实现公平的MNCH服务和成果,并定期监测这些策略的有效性。