Hiew Fu Liong, Rajabally Yusuf A
Regional Neuromuscular Clinic, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, University Hospitals of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Regional Neuromuscular Clinic, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, University Hospitals of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2016 Feb;127(2):1683-1688. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2015.09.131. Epub 2015 Sep 30.
To ascertain the impact of definition and diagnostic criteria on sural sparing in Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS).
We retrospectively reviewed records of 78 consecutive patients with GBS from Birmingham, UK (2001-2012) studied within 21 days post-onset. Different criteria were initially used for subtype classification. Sural sparing was subsequently ascertained using historical/recent definitions.
With Hadden et al.'s criteria, "absent median present sural" and "absent median normal sural" patterns offered sensitivities of 21.7% and 15.2% respectively for AIDP, with specificities of 100% versus axonal GBS. Present sural with two abnormal upper limb responses had a sensitivity of 19.1% and 100% specificity. "Abnormal radial present sural" and "abnormal radial normal sural" patterns had sensitivities of 18.9% and 16.2% and specificity of 100%. With newly-proposed criteria (Rajabally et al., 2015), "absent median present sural" and "absent median normal sural" patterns offered sensitivities of 27.8% and 19.4% respectively, with specificity of 100%. Ulnar patterns were unhelpful with both criteria. Other patterns had suboptimal specificity.
Although of low sensitivity, sural sparing defined by absent median/present sural patterns, is specific of AIDP versus axonal GBS, irrespective of criteria.
Sural sparing is definition and criteria-dependent in GBS but is specific of AIDP with historical definitions, regardless of criteria.
确定定义和诊断标准对吉兰 - 巴雷综合征(GBS)中腓肠神经保留的影响。
我们回顾性分析了英国伯明翰78例连续GBS患者(2001 - 2012年)发病后21天内的记录。最初使用不同标准进行亚型分类。随后使用历史/最新定义确定腓肠神经保留情况。
根据哈登等人的标准,“正中神经缺失,腓肠神经存在”和“正中神经缺失,腓肠神经正常”模式对急性炎症性脱髓鞘性多发性神经病(AIDP)的敏感性分别为21.7%和15.2%,与轴索性GBS相比特异性为100%。腓肠神经存在且上肢有两个异常反应的敏感性为19.1%,特异性为100%。“桡神经异常,腓肠神经存在”和“桡神经异常,腓肠神经正常”模式的敏感性分别为18.9%和16.2%,特异性为100%。根据新提出的标准(拉贾巴利等人,2015年),“正中神经缺失,腓肠神经存在”和“正中神经缺失,腓肠神经正常”模式的敏感性分别为27.8%和19.4%,特异性为100%。两种标准下尺神经模式均无帮助。其他模式的特异性欠佳。
尽管敏感性较低,但无论采用何种标准,由正中神经缺失/腓肠神经存在模式定义的腓肠神经保留对AIDP与轴索性GBS具有特异性。
GBS中腓肠神经保留情况取决于定义和标准,但无论采用何种标准,根据历史定义对AIDP具有特异性。