Galvin J, Suominen E, Morgan C, O'Connell E-J, Smith A P
School of Psychology, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK.
J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2015 Dec;22(10):773-83. doi: 10.1111/jpm.12273. Epub 2015 Oct 12.
What is known on the subject? Stress can impact students on mental health nurse training. This can have implications at the individual level (e.g. their own mental health) and at the level of the organization (e.g. sickness absence and attrition). What this paper adds to existing knowledge? We interviewed 12 mental health nursing students regarding the stress they experienced during training. Participants described how the academic demands can at times be unbearable during clinical placements. There were also issues with 'being a student' on some placements, with participants describing negative attitudes towards them from staff. The younger participants reported feeling overwhelmed on their initial placements and described some of the main challenges of mental health work for them. Raising concerns about the quality of care on wards was also described as particularly challenging for the students. What are the implications for practice? This paper can be useful to help training providers support mental health nursing students. Recommendations include reducing academic demands during clinical placements and extending and promoting existing support services beyond normal 9 am-5 pm working hours, even if these services are limited. Younger students could be better supported by being allocated to the more well-resourced placements in the early stages of their training. Raising awareness among staff of the tasks students can and cannot perform can help improve staff/student relations. Finally, students should be educated about the issues around raising concerns on placements to help the government's drive for a more open and transparent National Health Service (NHS).
Previous studies investigating stress in nursing students focus on general nursing students or adopt quantitative measures.
A qualitative study focusing specifically on mental health nursing students is required.
One-to-one interviews were carried out with mental health nursing students (n = 12). Data were thematically analysed.
Participants reported unreasonable demands during clinical blocks, and described how control/support is lowest on placements with staff shortages. Negative attitudes towards students from staff and related issues were also discussed. Younger participants described struggling with mental health work during the early stages of training.
Training providers should strive to provide adequate support to students to help them manage stress during training. Implications for practice Academic demands should be reasonable during clinical blocks and support services outside normal working hours should be available for students, even if these are limited in scope. Greater consideration to the allocation of placements for younger students in the mental health branch could be helpful. Furthermore, staff on placements should be aware of the tasks students can and cannot perform, to help improve staff/student relations. Educating students on the issues of raising concerns can help the government's drive for a more open and transparent National Health Service (NHS).
关于该主题已知的内容有哪些?压力会对接受心理健康护理培训的学生产生影响。这可能在个人层面(例如他们自身的心理健康)和组织层面(例如病假和人员流失)产生影响。本文对现有知识的补充是什么?我们采访了12名心理健康护理专业学生,了解他们在培训期间所经历的压力。参与者描述了在临床实习期间学术要求有时如何难以承受。在一些实习中还存在“作为学生”的问题,参与者描述了工作人员对他们的负面态度。较年轻的参与者报告说在最初的实习中感到不堪重负,并描述了心理健康工作对他们来说的一些主要挑战。对病房护理质量提出担忧对学生来说也被描述为特别具有挑战性。对实践有哪些影响?本文有助于培训提供者支持心理健康护理专业学生。建议包括在临床实习期间降低学术要求,以及在正常上午9点至下午5点工作时间之外扩展和推广现有的支持服务,即使这些服务有限。在培训早期将较年轻的学生分配到资源更丰富的实习岗位上,可以更好地支持他们。提高工作人员对学生能够和不能执行的任务的认识,有助于改善工作人员与学生的关系。最后,应该对学生进行关于在实习中提出担忧相关问题的教育,以帮助政府推动建立一个更加开放和透明的国民医疗服务体系(NHS)。
以往调查护理专业学生压力的研究主要集中在普通护理专业学生或采用定量测量方法。
需要一项专门针对心理健康护理专业学生的定性研究。
对心理健康护理专业学生(n = 12)进行一对一访谈。对数据进行主题分析。
参与者报告在临床实习期间存在不合理要求,并描述了在人员短缺的实习岗位上控制/支持最少的情况。还讨论了工作人员对学生的负面态度及相关问题。较年轻的参与者描述了在培训早期应对心理健康工作的困难。
培训提供者应努力为学生提供充分支持,以帮助他们在培训期间应对压力。对实践的影响在临床实习期间学术要求应合理,并且应为学生提供正常工作时间之外的支持服务,即使这些服务范围有限。更多地考虑为心理健康专业较年轻的学生分配实习岗位可能会有所帮助。此外,实习岗位上的工作人员应了解学生能够和不能执行的任务,以帮助改善工作人员与学生的关系。对学生进行关于提出担忧问题的教育,有助于政府推动建立一个更加开放和透明的国民医疗服务体系(NHS)。