Coghlan Renia, Gardiner Elizabeth, Amanullah Farhana, Ihekweazu Chikwe, Triasih Rina, Grzemska Malgorzata, Sismanidis Charalambos
TESS Development Advisors, Geneva, Switzerland.
Consultant, New York, New York, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2015 Oct 13;10(10):e0138323. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0138323. eCollection 2015.
We sought to understand gaps in reporting childhood TB cases among public and private sector health facilities (dubbed "non-NTP" facilities) outside the network of national TB control programmes, and the resulting impact of under-reporting on estimates of paediatric disease burden and market demand for new medicines.
Exploratory assessments were carried out in Indonesia, Nigeria and Pakistan, reaching a range of facility types in two selected areas of each country. Record reviews and interviews of healthcare providers were carried out to assess numbers of unreported paediatric TB cases, diagnostic pathways followed and treatment regimens prescribed.
A total of 985 unreported diagnosed paediatric TB cases were identified over a three month period in 2013 in Indonesia from 64 facilities, 463 in Pakistan from 35 facilities and 24 in Nigeria from 20 facilities. These represent an absolute additional annualised yield to 2013 notifications reported to WHO of 15% for Indonesia, 2% for Nigeria and 7% for Pakistan. Only 12% of all facilities provided age and sex-disaggregated data. Findings highlight the challenges of confirming childhood TB. Diagnosis patterns in Nigeria highlight a very low suspicion for childhood TB. Providers note the need for paediatric medicines aligned to WHO recommendations.
This study emphasises the impact of incomplete reporting on the estimation of disease burden and potential market size of paediatric TB medicines. Further studies on "hubs" (facilities treating large numbers of childhood TB cases) will improve our understanding of the epidemic, support introduction efforts for new treatments and better measure markets for new paediatric medicines.
我们试图了解在国家结核病控制规划网络之外的公共和私营部门卫生设施(称为“非国家结核病规划”设施)报告儿童结核病病例方面存在的差距,以及报告不足对儿科疾病负担估计和新药市场需求产生的影响。
在印度尼西亚、尼日利亚和巴基斯坦开展了探索性评估,覆盖每个国家两个选定地区的一系列设施类型。进行了记录审查并与医疗服务提供者进行访谈,以评估未报告的儿科结核病病例数量、遵循的诊断途径和规定的治疗方案。
2013年,在三个月的时间里,印度尼西亚64家设施共发现985例未报告的确诊儿科结核病病例,巴基斯坦35家设施发现463例,尼日利亚20家设施发现24例。这些病例相当于2013年向世卫组织报告的通报病例数的绝对年度新增病例数,印度尼西亚为15%,尼日利亚为2%,巴基斯坦为7%。所有设施中只有12%提供了按年龄和性别分类的数据。研究结果凸显了确诊儿童结核病的挑战。尼日利亚的诊断模式表明对儿童结核病的怀疑度非常低。医疗服务提供者指出需要符合世卫组织建议的儿科药物。
市场数据如何支持更好的公共卫生干预措施:本研究强调了报告不完整对儿科结核病药物疾病负担估计和潜在市场规模的影响。对“枢纽”(治疗大量儿童结核病病例的设施)的进一步研究将增进我们对该流行病的了解,支持新治疗方法的引进工作,并更好地衡量新儿科药物的市场。