Malysheva Anzhela, Ivask Angela, Hager Claudia, Brunetti Gianluca, Marzouk Ezzat R, Lombi Enzo, Voelcker Nicolas H
a Centre for Environmental Risk Assessment and Remediation, University of South Australia , Mawson Lakes , Australia .
b Mawson Institute, University of South Australia , Mawson Lakes , Australia , and.
Nanotoxicology. 2016;10(4):385-90. doi: 10.3109/17435390.2015.1084059. Epub 2015 Oct 15.
Here, we evaluate the extent of sorption of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) with different primary sizes (30 and 70 nm) and surface properties (branched polyethylene imine, "bPEI" and citrate coating) to laboratory plastic during (eco)toxicological testing. Under conditions of algal growth inhibition assay, up to 97% of the added AgNPs were sorbed onto the test vessels whereas under conditions of in vitro toxicological assay with mammalian cells, the maximum loss of AgNPs was 15%. We propose that the high concentration of proteins and biomolecules in the in vitro toxicological assay originating from serum-containing cell culture medium prevented NP sorption due to steric stabilisation. The sorption of AgNPs to test vessels was clearly concentration dependent. In the conditions of algal growth inhibition assay at 10 ng AgNPs/mL, up to 97% of AgNPs were lost from the test while at higher concentrations (1000 ng AgNPs/mL), the loss of AgNPs was remarkably smaller, up to 64%. Sorption of positively charged bPEI-coated AgNPs was more extensive than the sorption of negatively charged citrate-coated AgNPs and, when calculated on a mass basis, more 70 nm-sized Ag than 30 nm Ag sorbed to plastic surfaces. In summary, this study demonstrates that the loss of AgNPs during (eco)toxicological tests due to sorption on test vessel surfaces is significant, especially in diluted media (e.g. in algal growth medium) and at low NP concentrations. Thus, to ensure the accurate interpretation of (eco)toxicological results, the loss of AgNPs due to adsorption to test vessels should not be overlooked and considered for each specific case.
在此,我们评估了不同初始尺寸(30和70纳米)和表面性质(支化聚乙烯亚胺,“bPEI”和柠檬酸盐涂层)的银纳米颗粒(AgNPs)在(生态)毒理学测试期间对实验室塑料制品的吸附程度。在藻类生长抑制试验条件下,高达97%的添加AgNPs被吸附到测试容器上,而在哺乳动物细胞体外毒理学试验条件下,AgNPs的最大损失为15%。我们认为,体外毒理学试验中源自含血清细胞培养基的高浓度蛋白质和生物分子由于空间稳定作用阻止了纳米颗粒的吸附。AgNPs对测试容器的吸附明显依赖于浓度。在藻类生长抑制试验条件下,当AgNPs浓度为10纳克/毫升时,高达97%的AgNPs从测试中损失,而在较高浓度(1000纳克/毫升)时,AgNPs的损失明显较小,高达64%。带正电荷的bPEI包覆的AgNPs的吸附比带负电荷的柠檬酸盐包覆的AgNPs更广泛,并且以质量计算,吸附到塑料表面的70纳米尺寸的Ag比30纳米的Ag更多。总之,本研究表明,在(生态)毒理学测试期间,由于吸附在测试容器表面导致的AgNPs损失是显著的,尤其是在稀释介质(如藻类生长培养基)和低纳米颗粒浓度下。因此,为确保准确解释(生态)毒理学结果,不应忽视AgNPs因吸附到测试容器上而导致的损失,并应针对每个具体情况加以考虑。