Rogers Charles R, Mitchell Jamie A, Franta Gabriel J, Foster Margaret J, Shires Deirdre
1 University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
2 University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Am J Mens Health. 2017 Sep;11(5):1486-1500. doi: 10.1177/1557988315611227. Epub 2015 Oct 18.
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is highly preventable when CRC screening is utilized, yet CRC screening completion among African American men is relatively low and their mortality rates remain 50% higher juxtaposed to their White counterparts. Since a growing body of literature indicates masculinity, racism, and social support each have strong influences on CRC screening uptake, this systematic review examined the connections between these three sociocultural factors and CRC screening uptake among African American men. Potential studies were retrieved from MEDLINE, CINAHL, EMBASE, and PsycINFO. Cited reference searching for the final sample was employed to identify and assess additional studies for inclusion using Scopus. The methodological quality of the reviewed evidence was also evaluated. Nineteen studies met inclusion/exclusion criteria. Thirteen studies employed nonexperimental research designs; a quasi-experimental design was present in four, and two utilized experimental designs. Studies were published between 2000 and 2014; the majority between 2009 and 2013. Social support was most frequently addressed (84%) while masculinity and racism were equally studied with paucity (11%) for their influence on CRC screening. After evaluating conceptual and methodological characteristics of the studies, 42% fell below average in quality and rigor. The need for increased attention to the sociocultural correlates of CRC screening for African American men are highlighted in this systematic review, and important recommendations for research and practice are provided. Alongside a call for more rigorous research, further research examining the influence of masculinity and racism on CRC screening completion among African American men is warranted.
如果采用结直肠癌(CRC)筛查,这种癌症是高度可预防的。然而,非裔美国男性的CRC筛查完成率相对较低,与白人男性相比,他们的死亡率仍高出50%。由于越来越多的文献表明,男性气质、种族主义和社会支持对CRC筛查的接受度都有很大影响,因此本系统综述研究了这三个社会文化因素与非裔美国男性CRC筛查接受度之间的联系。潜在的研究从MEDLINE、CINAHL、EMBASE和PsycINFO中检索。使用Scopus对最终样本进行引用文献检索,以识别和评估其他纳入研究。还评估了所审查证据的方法学质量。19项研究符合纳入/排除标准。13项研究采用非实验性研究设计;4项采用准实验设计,2项采用实验设计。研究发表于2000年至2014年之间;大多数发表于2009年至2013年之间。社会支持是最常被提及的因素(84%),而男性气质和种族主义对CRC筛查影响的研究较少(均为11%)。在评估了这些研究的概念和方法学特征后,42%的研究在质量和严谨性方面低于平均水平。本系统综述强调了需要更多关注非裔美国男性CRC筛查的社会文化相关因素,并提供了重要的研究和实践建议。除了呼吁进行更严谨的研究外,还需要进一步研究男性气质和种族主义对非裔美国男性CRC筛查完成率的影响。