Lee Soo Eon, Jahng Tae-Ahn, Kim Hyun Jib
Department of Neurosurgery, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Int J Spine Surg. 2015 Aug 28;9:45. doi: 10.14444/2045. eCollection 2015.
As motion-preserving technique has been developed, the concept of hybrid surgery involves simultaneous application of two different kinds of devices, dynamic stabilization system and fusion technique. In the present study, the application of hybrid surgery for lumbosacral degenerative disease involving two-segments and its long-term outcome were investigated.
Fifteen patients with hybrid surgery (Hybrid group) and 10 patients with two-segment fusion (Fusion group) were retrospectively compared.
Preoperative grade for disc degeneration was not different between the two groups, and the most common operated segment had the most degenerated disc grade in both groups; L4-5 and L5-S1 in the Hybrid group, and L3-4 and L4-5 in Fusion group. Over 48 months of follow-up, lumbar lordosis and range of motion (ROM) at the T12-S1 global segment were preserved in the Hybrid group, and the segmental ROM at the dynamic stabilized segment maintained at final follow-up. The Fusion group had a significantly decreased global ROM and a decreased segmental ROM with larger angles compared to the Hybrid group. Defining a 2-mm decrease in posterior disc height (PDH) as radiologic adjacent segment pathology (ASP), these changes were observed in 6 and 7 patients in the Hybrid and Fusion group, respectively. However, the last PDH at the above adjacent segment had statistically higher value in Hybrid group. Pain score for back and legs was much reduced in both groups. Functional outcome measured by Oswestry disability index (ODI), however, had better improvement in Hybrid group.
Hybrid surgery, combined dynamic stabilization system and fusion, can be effective surgical treatment for multilevel degenerative lumbosacral spinal disease, maintaining lumbar motion and delaying disc degeneration.
随着保留运动功能技术的发展,混合手术的概念涉及同时应用两种不同的装置,即动态稳定系统和融合技术。在本研究中,对涉及两个节段的腰骶部退行性疾病应用混合手术及其长期疗效进行了研究。
回顾性比较了15例行混合手术的患者(混合组)和10例行两节段融合手术的患者(融合组)。
两组术前椎间盘退变分级无差异,两组中最常手术的节段椎间盘退变分级最高;混合组为L4-5和L5-S1,融合组为L3-4和L4-5。随访超过48个月,混合组T12-S1整体节段的腰椎前凸和活动度(ROM)得以保留,动态稳定节段的节段性ROM在末次随访时保持稳定。与混合组相比,融合组的整体ROM显著降低,节段性ROM减少角度更大。将椎间盘后高度(PDH)下降2mm定义为影像学相邻节段病变(ASP),混合组和融合组分别有6例和7例出现这些变化。然而,上述相邻节段的末次PDH在混合组具有统计学上更高的值。两组的腰腿痛评分均显著降低。然而,以Oswestry功能障碍指数(ODI)衡量的功能结局在混合组改善更好。
结合动态稳定系统和融合的混合手术可有效治疗多节段腰骶部退行性脊柱疾病,维持腰椎活动并延缓椎间盘退变。