Magrabi Farah, Liaw Siaw Teng, Arachi Diana, Runciman William, Coiera Enrico, Kidd Michael R
Centre for Health Informatics, Australian Institute of Health Innovation, Macquarie University, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Centre for Primary Health Care and Equity, University of New South Wales, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
BMJ Qual Saf. 2016 Nov;25(11):870-880. doi: 10.1136/bmjqs-2015-004323. Epub 2015 Nov 5.
To identify the categories of problems with information technology (IT), which affect patient safety in general practice.
General practitioners (GPs) reported incidents online or by telephone between May 2012 and November 2013. Incidents were reviewed against an existing classification for problems associated with IT and the clinical process impacted.
87 GPs across Australia.
Types of problems, consequences and clinical processes.
GPs reported 90 incidents involving IT which had an observable impact on the delivery of care, including actual patient harm as well as near miss events. Practice systems and medications were the most affected clinical processes. Problems with IT disrupted clinical workflow, wasted time and caused frustration. Issues with user interfaces, routine updates to software packages and drug databases, and the migration of records from one package to another generated clinical errors that were unique to IT; some could affect many patients at once. Human factors issues gave rise to some errors that have always existed with paper records but are more likely to occur and cause harm with IT. Such errors were linked to slips in concentration, multitasking, distractions and interruptions. Problems with patient identification and hybrid records generated errors that were in principle no different to paper records.
Problems associated with IT include perennial risks with paper records, but additional disruptions in workflow and hazards for patients unique to IT, occasionally affecting multiple patients. Surveillance for such hazards may have general utility, but particularly in the context of migrating historical records to new systems and software updates to existing systems.
确定影响全科医疗中患者安全的信息技术(IT)问题类别。
全科医生(GPs)在2012年5月至2013年11月期间通过在线或电话报告事件。根据现有的IT相关问题及受影响临床过程的分类对事件进行审查。
澳大利亚各地的87名全科医生。
问题类型、后果及临床过程。
全科医生报告了90起涉及IT的事件,这些事件对医疗服务的提供产生了明显影响,包括实际的患者伤害以及险些发生的事件。实践系统和药物是受影响最严重的临床过程。IT问题扰乱了临床工作流程,浪费了时间并导致了挫败感。用户界面问题、软件包和药物数据库的常规更新以及记录从一个软件包迁移到另一个软件包产生了IT特有的临床错误;有些错误可能会同时影响许多患者。人为因素问题导致了一些纸质记录中一直存在但在IT环境下更易发生且会造成伤害的错误。此类错误与注意力不集中、多任务处理、分心和干扰有关。患者识别和混合记录问题产生的错误原则上与纸质记录无异。
与IT相关的问题包括纸质记录中长期存在的风险,但也有工作流程的额外干扰以及IT特有的患者风险,偶尔会影响多名患者。对此类风险的监测可能具有普遍用途,尤其是在将历史记录迁移到新系统以及对现有系统进行软件更新的情况下。