George Jessica A, Park Paul S, Hunsberger Joanne, Shay Joanne E, Lehmann Christoph U, White Elizabeth D, Lee Benjamin H, Yaster Myron
From the Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland; Departments of Pediatrics and Biomedical Informatics, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee; and Department of Pediatrics, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland.
Anesth Analg. 2016 Mar;122(3):807-813. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000001081.
Prescription errors are among the most common types of iatrogenic errors. Because of a previously reported 82% error rate in handwritten discharge narcotic prescriptions, we developed a computerized, web-based, controlled substance prescription writer that includes weight-based dosing logic and alerts to reduce the error rate to (virtually) zero. Over the past 7 years, >34,000 prescriptions have been created by hospital providers using this platform. We sought to determine the ongoing efficacy of the program in prescription error reduction and the patterns with which providers prescribe controlled substances for children and young adults (ages 0-21 years) at hospital discharge.
We examined a database of 34,218 controlled substance discharge prescriptions written by our institutional providers from January 1, 2007 to February 14, 2014, for demographic information, including age and weight, type of medication prescribed based on patient age, formulation of dispensed medication, and amount of drug to be dispensed at hospital discharge. In addition, we randomly regenerated 2% (700) of prescriptions based on stored data and analyzed them for errors using previously established error criteria. Weights that were manually entered into the prescription writer by the prescriber were compared with the patient's weight in the hospital's electronic medical record.
Patients in the database averaged 9 ± 6.1 (range, 0-21) years of age and 36.7 ± 24.9 (1-195) kg. Regardless of age, the most commonly prescribed opioid was oxycodone (73%), which was prescribed as a single agent uncombined with acetaminophen. Codeine was prescribed to 7% of patients and always in a formulation containing acetaminophen. Liquid formulations were prescribed to 98% of children <6 years of age and to 16% of children >12 years of age (the remaining 84% received tablet formulations). Regardless of opioid prescribed, the amount of liquid dispensed averaged 106 ± 125 (range, 2-3240) mL, and the number of tablets dispensed averaged 51 ± 51 (range, 1-1080). Of the subset of 700 regenerated prescriptions, all were legible (drug, amount dispensed, dose, patient demographics, and provider name) and used best prescribing practice (e.g., no trailing zero after a decimal point, leading zero for doses <1). Twenty-five of the 700 (3.6%) had incorrectly entered weights compared with the most recent weight in the chart. Of these, 14 varied by 10% or less and only 2 varied by >15%. Of these, 1 resulted in underdosing (true weight 80 kg prescribed for a weight of 50 kg) and the other in overdosing (true weight 10 kg prescribed for a weight of 30 kg).
A computerized prescription writer eliminated most but not all the errors common to handwritten prescriptions. Oxycodone has supplanted codeine as the most commonly prescribed oral opioid in current pediatric pain practice and, independent of formulation, is dispensed in large quantities. This study underscores the need for liquid opioid formulations in the pediatric population and, because of their abuse potential, the urgent need to determine how much of the prescribed medication is actually used by patients.
处方错误是最常见的医源性错误类型之一。鉴于此前报告的手写出院麻醉处方错误率达82%,我们开发了一种基于网络的计算机化管制药品处方书写程序,该程序包含基于体重的给药逻辑和警报功能,可将错误率降低至(几乎)零。在过去7年中,医院医护人员使用这个平台开出了超过34000份处方。我们试图确定该程序在减少处方错误方面的持续有效性,以及医护人员在医院出院时为儿童和青少年(0至21岁)开具管制药品的模式。
我们检查了一个数据库,其中包含2007年1月1日至2014年2月14日期间我院医护人员开具的34218份管制药品出院处方,以获取人口统计学信息,包括年龄和体重、根据患者年龄开具的药物类型、配发药物的剂型以及出院时要配发的药物量。此外,我们根据存储的数据随机重新生成了2%(700份)的处方,并使用先前确定的错误标准对其进行错误分析。将开方者手动输入处方书写程序的体重与医院电子病历中的患者体重进行比较。
数据库中的患者平均年龄为9±6.1岁(范围为0至21岁),平均体重为36.7±24.9千克(1至195千克)。无论年龄大小,最常开具的阿片类药物是羟考酮(73%),它作为单一药物开具,未与对乙酰氨基酚联合使用。7%的患者开具了可待因,且总是开具含对乙酰氨基酚的剂型。98%的6岁以下儿童和16%的12岁以上儿童开具了液体制剂(其余84%接受片剂剂型)。无论开具何种阿片类药物,配发的液体平均量为106±125毫升(范围为2至3240毫升),配发的片剂平均数量为51±51片(范围为1至1080片)。在重新生成的700份处方子集中,所有处方都清晰可读(药物、配发量、剂量、患者人口统计学信息和开方者姓名),并采用了最佳处方规范(例如,小数点后无尾随零,剂量小于1时前面有零)。与病历中最新体重相比,700份处方中有25份(3.6%)的体重输入错误。其中,14份的差异在10%或以下,只有2份的差异超过15%。其中1份导致剂量不足(实际体重50千克,处方为80千克),另1份导致剂量过量(实际体重30千克,处方为10千克)。
计算机化处方书写程序消除了大多数但并非所有手写处方常见的错误。在当前儿科疼痛治疗中,羟考酮已取代可待因成为最常开具的口服阿片类药物,且无论剂型如何,其配发量都很大。这项研究强调了儿科人群对阿片类液体制剂的需求,并且由于其具有滥用潜力,迫切需要确定患者实际使用了多少处方药物。