Györfi O, Moarcas M, Balicza P, Macerollo A, Struhal W, Sellner J
Department of Neurology, Nyírő Gyula Hospital - National Institute of Psychiatry and Addiction, Budapest, Hungary.
Department of Neurology, Brasov County Emergency Hospital, Brasov, Romania.
Acta Neurol Scand. 2016 Sep;134(3):232-7. doi: 10.1111/ane.12533. Epub 2015 Nov 23.
Whether residency programs in Europe and neighboring countries appropriately prepare one for clinical practice is a matter of discussion.
To assess perceived satisfaction and preparedness for clinical practice among residents and junior neurologists from Europe and neighboring countries.
We inquired about the level of satisfaction with the quality of teaching, rotations and research opportunities of their residency program with an anonymous paper-based questionnaire. We assessed different aspects of practical training including clinical examination, diagnostic procedures, and patient management.
The survey revealed limited satisfaction with the overall training (47%). The quality of teaching was frequently perceived as good or excellent (73%), whereas supervision for patient care and diagnostic procedures was rated as improvable. Discontent related often to poor proficiency for neurological emergencies, diagnostic considerations, and therapeutic decisions. Whether the working time directive introduced by the European Union (EU) affected patient care or resident education or residents' quality of life remained ambiguous.
This cross-sectional survey disclosed shortcomings in current residency curricula. These concerned diagnostic and therapeutic procedures as well as practical skills, regardless of country, region, or institutional background. Initiatives aimed to harmonize postgraduate neurology training across Europe will need to consider these findings.
欧洲及周边国家的住院医师培训项目是否能让学员为临床实践做好充分准备是一个备受讨论的问题。
评估欧洲及周边国家住院医师和初级神经科医生对临床实践的满意度及准备情况。
我们通过一份匿名纸质问卷,询问他们对住院医师培训项目教学质量、轮转安排和研究机会的满意度。我们评估了实践培训的不同方面,包括临床检查、诊断程序和患者管理。
调查显示对整体培训的满意度有限(47%)。教学质量常被认为良好或优秀(73%),而对患者护理和诊断程序的监督被认为有待改进。不满往往与神经科急症、诊断考量和治疗决策方面的能力不足有关。欧盟引入的工作时间指令是否影响患者护理、住院医师教育或住院医师的生活质量仍不明确。
这项横断面调查揭示了当前住院医师培训课程存在的不足。这些不足涉及诊断和治疗程序以及实践技能,无论国家、地区或机构背景如何。旨在协调欧洲研究生神经科培训的举措需要考虑这些发现。