Pisa Federica Edith, Casetta Anica, Clagnan Elena, Michelesio Elisa, Vecchi Brumatti Liza, Barbone Fabio
Institute of Hygiene and Clinical Epidemiology, University Hospital of Udine, Via Colugna 50, 33100, Udine, Italy.
Department of Medical and Biological Sciences, University of Udine, Udine, Italy.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2015 Nov 25;15:310. doi: 10.1186/s12884-015-0745-3.
Health databases are a promising resource for epidemiological studies on medications safety during pregnancy. The reliability of information on medications exposure and pregnancy timing is a key methodological issue. This study (a) compared maternal self-reports and database information on medication use, gestational age, date of delivery; (b) quantified the degree of agreement between sources; (c) assessed predictors of agreement.
Pregnant women recruited in a prenatal clinic in Friuli Venezia Giulia (FVG) region, Italy, from 2007 to 2009, completed a questionnaire inquiring on medication use during pregnancy, gestational age and date of delivery. Redeemed prescriptions and birth certificate records were extracted from regional databases through record linkage. Percent agreement, Kappa coefficient, prevalence and bias-adjusted Kappa (PABAK) were calculated. Odds Ratio (OR), with 95% confidence interval (95% CI), of ≥ 1 agreement was calculated through unconditional logistic regression.
The cohort included 767 women, 39.8% reported medication use, and 70.5% were dispensed at least one medication. Kappa and PABAK indicated almost perfect to substantial agreement for antihypertensive medications (Kappa 0.86, PABAK 0.99), thyroid hormones (0.88, 0.98), antiepileptic medications (1.00, 1.00), antithrombotic agents (0.70, 0.96). PABAK value was greater than Kappa for medications such as insulin (Kappa 0.50, PABAK 0.99), antihistamines for systemic use (0.50, 0.99), progestogens (0.28, 0.79), and antibiotics (0.12, 0.63). Adjusted OR was 0.48 (95% CI 0.26; 0.90) in ex- vs. never smokers, 0.64 (0.38; 1.08) in < high school vs. university, 1.55 (1.01; 2.37) in women with comorbidities, 2.25 (1.19; 4.26) in those aged 40+ vs. 30-34 years. Gestational age matched exactly in 85.2% and date of delivery in 99.5%.
For selected medications used for chronic conditions, the agreement between self-reports and dispensing data was high. For medications with low to very low prevalence of use, PABAK provides a more reliable measure of agreement. Maternal reports and dispensing data are complementary to each other to increase the reliability of information on the use of medications during pregnancy. Birth certificates provide reliable data on the timing of pregnancy. FVG health databases are a valuable source of data for pregnancy research.
健康数据库是孕期药物安全性流行病学研究的一个有前景的资源。药物暴露和孕周信息的可靠性是一个关键的方法学问题。本研究(a)比较了母亲关于药物使用、孕周、分娩日期的自我报告与数据库信息;(b)量化了不同来源之间的一致程度;(c)评估了一致性的预测因素。
2007年至2009年在意大利弗留利-威尼斯朱利亚(FVG)地区的一家产前诊所招募的孕妇,完成了一份关于孕期药物使用、孕周和分娩日期的问卷。通过记录链接从地区数据库中提取已兑现的处方和出生证明记录。计算百分比一致性、卡帕系数、患病率和偏差调整卡帕(PABAK)。通过无条件逻辑回归计算一致性≥1的比值比(OR)及其95%置信区间(95%CI)。
该队列包括767名女性,39.8%报告使用过药物,70.5%至少配过一种药物。卡帕和PABAK表明抗高血压药物(卡帕0.86,PABAK 0.99)、甲状腺激素(0.88,0.98)、抗癫痫药物(1.00,1.00)、抗血栓药物(0.70,0.96)的一致性几乎完美到高度一致。对于胰岛素(卡帕0.50,PABAK 0.99)、全身用抗组胺药(0.50,0.99)、孕激素(0.28,0.79)和抗生素(0.12,0.63)等药物,PABAK值大于卡帕。曾经吸烟者与从不吸烟者相比,调整后的OR为0.48(95%CI 0.26;0.90),高中以下学历与大学学历相比为0.64(0.38;1.08),有合并症的女性为1.55(1.01;2.37),40岁及以上与30 - 34岁的女性相比为2.25(1.19;4.26)。孕周完全匹配的占85.2%,分娩日期完全匹配的占99.5%。
对于用于慢性病的特定药物,自我报告与配药数据之间的一致性较高。对于使用患病率低至极低的药物,PABAK提供了更可靠的一致性测量方法。母亲报告和配药数据相互补充,以提高孕期药物使用信息的可靠性。出生证明提供了关于孕期时间的可靠数据。FVG健康数据库是孕期研究的宝贵数据来源。