Avari Hamed, Savory Eric, Rogers Kem A
Advanced Fluid Mechanics Research Group, Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, University of Western Ontario, London, ON, N6A 5B8, Canada.
Department of Anatomy and Cell Biology, University of Western Ontario, London, ON, N6A 5B8, Canada.
Cardiovasc Eng Technol. 2016 Mar;7(1):44-57. doi: 10.1007/s13239-015-0250-x. Epub 2015 Nov 30.
Numerous in vitro systems have previously been developed and employed for studying the effects of hemodynamics on endothelial cell (EC) dysfunction. In the majority of that work, accurate flow quantification (e.g., uniformity of the flow over the ECs) remains elusive and wall shear stress (WSS) quantifications are determined using theoretical relationships (without considering the flow channel aspect ratio effects). In addition, those relationships are not applicable to flows other than steady laminar cases. The present work discusses the development of a novel hemodynamic flow system for studying the effects of various well-quantified flow regimes over ECs. The current work presents a novel hemodynamic flow system applying the concept of a parallel plate flow chamber (PPFC) with live microscopy access for studying the effects of quantified WSS on ECs. A range of steady laminar, pulsatile (carotid wave form) and low-Reynolds number turbulent WSSs were quantified through velocity field measurements by a laser Doppler velocimetry (LDV) system, to validate the functionality of the current hemodynamic flow system. Uniformity of the flow across the channel width can be analyzed with the current system (e.g., the flow was uniform across about 65-75% of the channel width for the steady cases). The WSS obtained from the experiments had higher values in almost all of the cases when compared to the most commonly-used theoretical solution (9% < error < 16%), whereas another relationship, which considers the channel dimensions, had better agreement with the experimental results (1% < error < 8%). Additionally, the latter relationship predicted the uniform flow region in the PPFC with an average difference of <5% when compared to the experimental results. The experimental data also showed that the WSS at various locations (D, E and F) at the test section differed by less than 4% for the laminar cases representing a fully developed flow. WSS was also determined for a low-Re (Re = 2750) turbulent flow using (1) the Reynolds shears stress and (2) the time-averaged velocity profile gradient at the wall, with a good agreement (differences <16%) between the two where the first method returned a higher value than the second. Porcine aortic endothelial cell (PAEC) viability in the system and morphological cell response to laminar WSS of about 11 dyne/cm(2), were observed. These results provide performance validation of this novel in vitro system with many improved features compared to previous similar prototypes for investigation of flow effects on ECs. The integration of the LDV technique in the current study and the comparison of the results with those from theory revealed that great care must be taken when using PPFCs since the commonly used theoretical relation for laminar steady flows is unable to predict the flow uniformity (which may introduce significant statistical bias in biological studies) and the predicted WSS was subjected to greater error when compared to a more comprehensive equation presented in the current work. Moreover, application of the LDV technique in the current system is essential for studies of more complex cases, such as disturbed flows, where the WSS cannot be predicted using theoretical or numerical modelling methods.
此前已开发并采用了许多体外系统来研究血流动力学对内皮细胞(EC)功能障碍的影响。在大多数此类研究中,准确的流量量化(例如,EC上血流的均匀性)仍然难以实现,壁面切应力(WSS)的量化是通过理论关系来确定的(未考虑流道纵横比的影响)。此外,这些关系不适用于除稳定层流情况之外的其他流动。本研究讨论了一种新型血流动力学流动系统的开发,该系统用于研究各种精确量化的流动状态对EC的影响。当前的研究提出了一种新型血流动力学流动系统,该系统应用了平行板流动腔(PPFC)的概念,并具备实时显微镜观察功能,用于研究量化的WSS对EC的影响。通过激光多普勒测速仪(LDV)系统进行速度场测量,对一系列稳定层流、脉动(颈动脉波形)和低雷诺数湍流的WSS进行了量化,以验证当前血流动力学流动系统的功能。利用当前系统可以分析流道宽度上的流动均匀性(例如,在稳定情况下,流动在约65 - 75%的流道宽度上是均匀的)。与最常用的理论解相比,实验得到的WSS在几乎所有情况下都具有更高的值(误差在9% <误差< 16%),而另一种考虑流道尺寸的关系与实验结果具有更好的一致性(误差在1% <误差< 8%)。此外,与实验结果相比,后一种关系预测的PPFC中的均匀流动区域平均差异小于5%。实验数据还表明,对于代表充分发展流动的层流情况,测试段不同位置(D、E和F)的WSS差异小于4%。还使用(1)雷诺剪应力和(2)壁面处的时间平均速度剖面梯度确定了低雷诺数(Re = 2750)湍流的WSS,两种方法之间具有良好的一致性(差异< 16%),其中第一种方法返回的值高于第二种方法。观察了该系统中猪主动脉内皮细胞(PAEC)的活力以及细胞对约11达因/平方厘米层流WSS的形态学反应。这些结果为这种新型体外系统提供了性能验证,与之前用于研究流动对EC影响的类似原型相比,该系统具有许多改进的特性。当前研究中LDV技术的整合以及结果与理论结果的比较表明,使用PPFC时必须格外小心,因为常用的层流稳定流动理论关系无法预测流动均匀性(这可能在生物学研究中引入显著的统计偏差),并且与当前工作中提出的更全面的方程相比,预测的WSS存在更大的误差。此外,在当前系统中应用LDV技术对于研究更复杂的情况(如紊乱流动)至关重要,在这些情况下,无法使用理论或数值建模方法预测WSS。