Bluck Susan, Alea Nicole, Baron-Lee Jacqueline M, Davis Danielle K
Department of Psychology, University of Florida.
Department of Behavioural Sciences, University of the West Indies.
Psychol Aging. 2016 Feb;31(1):42-57. doi: 10.1037/a0039990. Epub 2016 Jan 11.
Older adults sometimes exhibit higher levels of off-target verbosity during story recall than do young adults. This appears as the inclusion of extraneous information not directly relevant to the topic. Some production of such material has been clearly related to cognitive decline, particularly older adults' inability to inhibit production of irrelevant information. In tandem, however, research also suggests that some extraneous information is indirectly related to the topic and may reflect age differences in communicative styles. To further elucidate the social-cognitive aspect of this issue, the question of import is: What is the content of the additional information provided by participants during story recall? The present study answers this question. Grounded in the autobiographical memory and life story literatures, we introduce the construct, story asides, and a reliable content-analytic scheme for its assessment. Young and older adults (N = 129) recalled 1 of 2 types of stories: a personal autobiographical memory or an experimenter-generated fictional story. Narratives were reliably coded for story asides. As expected, older adults produced more story asides than young adults only for autobiographical stories. The discussion focuses on the role of story asides in everyday communication including the possibility that they may be a sign of communicative expertise.
与年轻人相比,老年人在故事回忆过程中有时会表现出更高水平的离题冗长。这表现为包含与主题不直接相关的额外信息。此类内容的产生显然与认知衰退有关,尤其是老年人无法抑制无关信息的产生。然而,与此同时,研究还表明,一些额外信息与主题间接相关,可能反映了交流方式上的年龄差异。为了进一步阐明这个问题的社会认知方面,关键问题是:参与者在故事回忆过程中提供的额外信息的内容是什么?本研究回答了这个问题。基于自传体记忆和生活故事文献,我们引入了“故事旁白”这一概念及其可靠的内容分析评估方案。年轻人和老年人(N = 129)回忆两种类型的故事中的一种:个人自传体记忆或实验者编写的虚构故事。对叙述内容进行可靠编码以确定故事旁白。正如预期的那样,仅在自传体故事中,老年人产生的故事旁白比年轻人更多。讨论聚焦于故事旁白在日常交流中的作用,包括它们可能是交流专长标志的可能性。