Effiong Utibe, Neitzel Richard L
Department of Environmental Health Sciences, University of Michigan, 1415 Washington Heights, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA.
Environ Health. 2016 Jan 19;15:7. doi: 10.1186/s12940-016-0089-0.
Geoengineering is the deliberate large-scale manipulation of environmental processes that affects the Earth's climate, in an attempt to counteract the effects of climate change. Injecting sulfate aerosol precursors and designed nanoparticles into the stratosphere to (i.e., solar radiation management [SRM]), has been suggested as one approach to geoengineering. Although much is being done to unravel the scientific and technical challenges around geoengineering, there have been few efforts to characterize the potential human health impacts of geoengineering, particularly with regards to SRM approaches involving stratospheric aerosols. This paper explores this information gap. Using available evidence, we describe the potential direct occupational and public health impacts of exposures to aerosols likely to be used for SRM, including environmental sulfates, black carbon, metallic aluminum, and aluminum oxide aerosols. We speculate on possible health impacts of exposure to one promising SRM material, barium titanate, using knowledge of similar nanomaterials. We also explore current regulatory efforts to minimize exposure to these toxicants. Our analysis suggests that adverse public health impacts may reasonably be expected from SRM via deployment of stratospheric aerosols. Little is known about the toxicity of some likely candidate aerosols, and there is no consensus regarding acceptable levels for public exposure to these materials. There is also little infrastructure in place to evaluate potential public health impacts in the event that stratospheric aerosols are deployed for solar radiation management. We offer several recommendations intended to help characterize the potential occupation and public health impacts of SRM, and suggest that a comprehensive risk assessment effort is needed before this approach to geoengineering receives further consideration.
地球工程是对影响地球气候的环境过程进行有意的大规模操纵,以试图抵消气候变化的影响。向平流层注入硫酸盐气溶胶前体和设计好的纳米颗粒(即太阳辐射管理[SRM]),已被提议作为地球工程的一种方法。尽管人们正在做大量工作来解决围绕地球工程的科学和技术挑战,但几乎没有努力去描述地球工程对人类健康的潜在影响,特别是涉及平流层气溶胶的太阳辐射管理方法。本文探讨了这一信息空白。利用现有证据,我们描述了接触可能用于太阳辐射管理的气溶胶对职业和公众健康的潜在直接影响,包括环境硫酸盐、黑碳、金属铝和氧化铝气溶胶。我们利用对类似纳米材料的了解,推测了接触一种有前景的太阳辐射管理材料钛酸钡可能产生的健康影响。我们还探讨了当前为尽量减少接触这些有毒物质所做的监管努力。我们的分析表明,通过部署平流层气溶胶进行太阳辐射管理可能会对公众健康产生不利影响。对于一些可能的候选气溶胶的毒性知之甚少,对于公众接触这些材料的可接受水平也没有达成共识。在为太阳辐射管理而部署平流层气溶胶的情况下,也几乎没有评估潜在公众健康影响的基础设施。我们提出了几项建议,旨在帮助描述太阳辐射管理对职业和公众健康的潜在影响,并建议在这种地球工程方法得到进一步考虑之前,需要进行全面的风险评估。