Padgett Deborah K, Smith Bikki Tran, Choy-Brown Mimi, Tiderington Emmy, Mercado Micaela
Dr. Padgett, Ms. Choy-Brown, and Dr. Mercado are with the Silver School of Social Work, New York University, New York City (e-mail:
Psychiatr Serv. 2016 Jun 1;67(6):610-4. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201500126. Epub 2016 Feb 14.
Recovery from mental illness is possible, but individuals with co-occurring disorders and homelessness face challenges. Although a nonlinear recovery course is assumed, few studies have analyzed recovery over time. This mixed-methods study examined recovery trajectories over 18 months after enrollment in supportive housing programs of 38 participants with DSM axis I diagnoses.
Qualitative interview data were quantified through consensual ratings to generate a recovery score for four waves of data collection based on eight recovery domains culled from the literature. Case study analyses were conducted of participants whose scores varied by one standard deviation or more between baseline and 18 months to identify which domains were important.
Most of the 38 participants (N=23) had no significant change in recovery; seven had a negative trajectory, and eight had a positive trajectory. Case studies of these 15 participants indicated domains that contributed to change: significant-other relationships (N=9), engagement in meaningful activities (N=9), mental health (N=7), family relationships (N=6), general medical health (N=5), housing satisfaction (N=5), employment (N=2), and substance use (N=1). Except for mental health and substance use (which contributed only to negative trajectories), the influence of domains was both positive and negative. Domains were intertwined; for example, variation in relationships was linked to changes in meaningful activities.
This study showed little change in recovery over time for most participants and a decline in mental health for a small minority. Findings underscore the importance of social relationships and meaningful activities among individuals with serious mental illness, who experience complex challenges.
精神疾病是有可能康复的,但同时患有多种疾病且无家可归的个体面临着诸多挑战。尽管假定康复过程是非线性的,但很少有研究分析随时间推移的康复情况。这项混合方法研究考察了38名被诊断为精神疾病诊断与统计手册(DSM)轴I障碍的参与者在入住支持性住房项目18个月后的康复轨迹。
通过共识评级对定性访谈数据进行量化,以便根据从文献中挑选出的八个康复领域,为四轮数据收集生成一个康复分数。对那些在基线和18个月之间分数变化一个标准差或更多的参与者进行案例研究分析,以确定哪些领域是重要的。
38名参与者中的大多数(N = 23)在康复方面没有显著变化;7人呈负向轨迹,8人呈正向轨迹。对这15名参与者的案例研究表明了促成变化的领域:重要他人关系(N = 9)、参与有意义的活动(N = 9)、心理健康(N = 7)、家庭关系(N = 6)、一般医疗健康(N = 5)、住房满意度(N = 5)、就业(N = 2)和物质使用(N = 1)。除了心理健康和物质使用(仅对负向轨迹有影响),各领域的影响既有正向的也有负向的。各领域相互交织;例如,人际关系的变化与有意义活动的变化相关。
这项研究表明,大多数参与者的康复情况随时间变化不大,少数人心理健康状况下降。研究结果强调了社会关系和有意义活动在面临复杂挑战的严重精神疾病患者中的重要性。