Jeong Min-Jeong, Lee Hye-Yoon, Lim Jung-Hwa, Yun Young-Ju
Department of Pediatrics, College of Korean Medicine, Useok University, Jeonju, Republic of Korea.
Department of Internal Medicine, Pusan National University Korean Medicine Hospital, Yangsan, Republic of Korea.
BMC Complement Altern Med. 2016 Mar 1;16:91. doi: 10.1186/s12906-016-1066-4.
Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is widespread but has various utilization rates according to country and the condition of patients. Generally, CAM is more frequently used in diseases that have no clear treatment method in conventional medicine. Therefore, a high utilization rate of CAM can be assumed in pediatric neurological diseases, but few studies have investigated the utilization of CAM in children with neuropsychiatric diseases. In particular, studies regarding the current use of CAM are scarce.
We conducted a survey of the parents or caregivers of patients who visited the pediatric rehabilitation clinic, pediatric neurology clinic, or pediatric psychiatry clinic at one university hospital from April to July 2011. We analyzed the factors that affect the utilization of CAM and other rehabilitation therapies.
Among the 578 patients recruited, 258 patients have ever received CAM (51.5%), and the current CAM utilization rate was 19.0% (110 patients). Two hundred patients (34.6%) were currently receiving only other rehabilitation therapies, and 268 patients (46.4%) were currently receiving no type of therapy. The rate of current CAM usage was significantly high in epilepsy patients. The ORs of 1-6-year-old and 7-12-year-old children compared with 13-19-year-old children were 3.14 (95 % CI 1.31-7.53) and 3.34 (95% CI 1.64-6.79), respectively, and the OR of the group with longer disease duration (≥48 months) compared with the group with shorter disease duration was 3.36 (95% CI 1.71-6.59). Only the age and disease duration showed statistically significant differences between the patients who were administered CAM and those who received other rehabilitation therapies (p < 0.0001).
CAM is preferred by patients under 13 years of age compared with patients aged 13-19 years, whereas other rehabilitation therapies are preferred by patients aged 1-6 years, followed by those aged 6-12 years and then by those aged 13-19 years. The patient's age and disease duration are the major factors influencing CAM use. Future studies should specify particular diseases, rather than combining all types of neuropsychiatric diseases, and include the socio-economic status of the parents.
补充和替代医学(CAM)应用广泛,但因国家和患者情况不同而有不同的使用率。一般来说,CAM在传统医学中尚无明确治疗方法的疾病中使用更为频繁。因此,可以推测CAM在儿科神经疾病中的使用率较高,但很少有研究调查其在患有神经精神疾病儿童中的应用情况。特别是,关于CAM当前使用情况的研究很少。
我们对2011年4月至7月在某大学医院儿科康复诊所、儿科神经科诊所或儿科精神科就诊患者的父母或照料者进行了一项调查。我们分析了影响CAM及其他康复治疗使用的因素。
在招募的578名患者中,258名患者曾接受过CAM治疗(51.5%),当前CAM使用率为19.0%(110名患者)。200名患者(34.6%)目前仅接受其他康复治疗,268名患者(46.4%)目前未接受任何治疗。癫痫患者当前CAM使用率显著较高。1 - 6岁和7 - 12岁儿童与13 - 19岁儿童相比的优势比分别为3.14(95%可信区间1.31 - 7.53)和3.34(95%可信区间1.64 - 6.79),疾病持续时间较长(≥48个月)组与疾病持续时间较短组相比的优势比为3.36(95%可信区间1.71 - 6.59)。在接受CAM治疗的患者与接受其他康复治疗的患者之间,仅年龄和疾病持续时间显示出统计学显著差异(p < 0.0001)。
与13 - 19岁患者相比,13岁以下患者更倾向于使用CAM,而1 - 6岁患者更倾向于接受其他康复治疗,其次是6 - 12岁患者,然后是13 - 19岁患者。患者的年龄和疾病持续时间是影响CAM使用的主要因素。未来的研究应针对特定疾病,而非将所有类型的神经精神疾病合并在一起,并纳入父母的社会经济状况。