Lauckner Heidi M, Hutchinson Susan L
School of Occupational Therapy, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada .
School of Health and Human Performance, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Rural Remote Health. 2016 Jan-Mar;16(1):3601. Epub 2016 Mar 5.
Chronic conditions are a growing healthcare concern. People living in rural regions are particularly affected because many barriers exist to accessing services and supports. Peer support for chronic condition self-management, where people living with chronic conditions learn about how to care for themselves and maintain their health from people also living with chronic conditions, is one approach gaining recognition. What remains unknown are the unique challenges and strategies associated with peer support for chronic condition self-management in rural contexts. In order to inform the development of peer supports in the authors' local context in rural eastern Canada, a scoping review was undertaken to discover community-based peer support initiatives for adults in rural settings living with chronic conditions.
The authors followed established scoping review methods to answer the research question What is known from the existing literature about the key features and potential formats of community-based peer support initiatives for adults living with chronic conditions in rural settings? Six databases (CINAHL, PubMed, Sociological Abstracts, Embase, Cochrane Libraries and PsycInfo) were searched using the following concepts: chronic conditions, peer support, community-based and rural context. Two researchers reviewed the titles and/or abstracts of the 1978 articles retrieved from the initial search to include articles that were in English, published in 2000 to 2014, and that explicitly discussed rural programs/interventions with peers that were community-based. The initial screen excluded 1907 articles, leaving 71 articles, which were read by two research members in light of the inclusion/exclusion criteria. Thirteen articles representing 10 separate programs were included and analyzed using qualitative content analysis.
Included programs were from the USA, Australia and Canada. A range of formats (telecommunications only, in-person meetings only, or a combination of both) were used. Peer leaders had varied experiences with chronic conditions and received training in content and facilitation skills. Peer leaders were provided with ongoing support. Program participants received training on chronic conditions, and programs provided opportunities for social support and the development of new skills. Programs focused on creating social connections, reducing stigma, ensuring relevance and promoting empowerment. Of the nine programs that reported outcomes, eight reported positive outcomes and one reported mixed results.
Consistent with the extant literature, the programs identified unique issues faced by people with chronic conditions in rural areas that these programs addressed. The key findings of this scoping review are as follows: 1. A combination of telecommunications with some face-to-face meetings can support the accessibility of peer support programs in rural areas. 2. Core elements of these programs are the provision of social support and skill development. 3. Peer leaders benefit from skills training and ongoing support. 4. Sustainability of such programs is complex and requires multiple strategies.
Cultural relevance, ongoing support and the use of telecommunications were key features of rural peer support programs. Guiding questions to facilitate a community consultation around these findings are provided. Peer support chronic condition self-management programs require further research.
慢性病日益成为医疗保健领域关注的焦点。生活在农村地区的人们受到的影响尤为显著,因为在获取服务和支持方面存在诸多障碍。同伴支持慢性疾病自我管理,即患有慢性病的人从同样患有慢性病的人那里学习如何自我护理和保持健康,是一种逐渐获得认可的方法。在农村环境中,与同伴支持慢性疾病自我管理相关的独特挑战和策略仍不为人所知。为了指导在加拿大东部农村地区作者当地开展同伴支持项目,进行了一项范围综述,以发现农村地区患有慢性病的成年人基于社区的同伴支持倡议。
作者遵循既定的范围综述方法来回答研究问题“现有文献中关于农村地区患有慢性病的成年人基于社区的同伴支持倡议的关键特征和潜在形式有哪些已知信息?”使用以下概念在六个数据库(CINAHL、PubMed、社会学文摘、Embase、Cochrane图书馆和PsycInfo)中进行搜索:慢性病、同伴支持、基于社区和农村环境。两名研究人员对从初始搜索中检索到的1978篇文章的标题和/或摘要进行了审查,以纳入2000年至2014年发表的英文文章,且这些文章明确讨论了与基于社区的同伴相关的农村项目/干预措施。初步筛选排除了1907篇文章,剩下71篇文章,由两名研究成员根据纳入/排除标准进行阅读。纳入并分析了代表10个不同项目的13篇文章,采用定性内容分析法。
纳入的项目来自美国、澳大利亚和加拿大。使用了多种形式(仅电信方式、仅面对面会议或两者结合)。同伴领袖在慢性病方面有不同经历,并接受了内容和促进技能方面的培训。为同伴领袖提供了持续支持。项目参与者接受了慢性病方面的培训,项目提供了社会支持和新技能发展的机会。项目侧重于建立社会联系、减少耻辱感、确保相关性和促进赋权。在报告结果的九个项目中,八个报告了积极结果,一个报告了混合结果。
与现有文献一致,所确定的项目解决了农村地区慢性病患者面临的独特问题。本次范围综述的主要发现如下:1. 电信与一些面对面会议相结合可以支持农村地区同伴支持项目的可及性。2. 这些项目的核心要素是提供社会支持和技能发展。3. 同伴领袖从技能培训和持续支持中受益。4. 此类项目的可持续性很复杂,需要多种策略。
文化相关性、持续支持和电信的使用是农村同伴支持项目的关键特征。提供了促进围绕这些发现进行社区咨询的指导性问题。同伴支持慢性疾病自我管理项目需要进一步研究。