Benstead Timothy, Jackson-Tarlton Caitlin, Leddin Desmond
1Division of Neurology,Department of Medicine,Dalhousie University,Halifax,Canada.
3Undergraduate Medicine,Dalhousie University,Halifax,Canada.
Can J Neurol Sci. 2016 Nov;43(6):796-800. doi: 10.1017/cjn.2016.28. Epub 2016 Apr 4.
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a rapidly progressing degenerative motor neuron disease that results in significant muscle weakness. Defects in energy metabolism and difficulties in swallowing eventually lead to a reduction in body mass. Weight loss exacerbates symptoms and serves as an independent negative prognostic factor. Percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) is often inserted in patients with ALS to either supplement or replace oral feeding. However, the criteria for PEG placement and timing of insertion are important clinical decisions that have not been fully studied. Given the absence of guiding evidence, the aim of this project was to better understand how Canadian ALS clinics make decisions regarding gastrostomy feeding.
ALS clinical directors across Canada were asked if they had written guidelines for timing of PEG insertion and if not, what criteria they use to make this decision. Responses from 10 of 17 centres contacted were received.
The approach to supplemental nutrition management in Canadian clinics varies in the absence of formal guidelines. Only one centre has a written set of centre-specific protocols in place. Most clinics considered some combination of respiratory decline, weight loss, dysphagia and/or patient readiness when reaching a decision. However, the absolute threshold and mechanism of measuring the individual criteria differed between clinics.
Practices generally reflect international published recommendations but vary on the emphasis of specific criteria. Further research is required to determine the optimal timing and criteria to place gastrostomy feeding tubes in the ALS population.
肌萎缩侧索硬化症(ALS)是一种进展迅速的退行性运动神经元疾病,会导致严重的肌肉无力。能量代谢缺陷和吞咽困难最终会导致体重下降。体重减轻会加重症状,并成为一个独立的不良预后因素。经皮内镜下胃造口术(PEG)常用于ALS患者,以补充或替代经口喂养。然而,PEG置入的标准和时机是重要的临床决策,尚未得到充分研究。鉴于缺乏指导性证据,本项目的目的是更好地了解加拿大的ALS诊所如何做出关于胃造口喂养的决策。
询问加拿大各地的ALS临床主任是否有关于PEG置入时机的书面指南,如果没有,他们依据什么标准做出这一决策。收到了17个联系中心中10个中心的回复。
在没有正式指南的情况下,加拿大各诊所补充营养管理的方法各不相同。只有一个中心制定了一套针对该中心的书面方案。大多数诊所在做出决策时会综合考虑呼吸功能下降、体重减轻、吞咽困难和/或患者意愿等因素。然而,各诊所对各个标准的绝对阈值和衡量机制有所不同。
实践做法总体上反映了国际上发表的建议,但在具体标准的侧重点上存在差异。需要进一步研究以确定在ALS患者中置入胃造口喂养管的最佳时机和标准。