Ng Joan Chung Yan, Leung Marianna, Landsberg David
BSc(Pharm), ACPR, was, at the time of this study, a Pharmacy Resident with Lower Mainland Pharmacy Services in Vancouver, British Columbia. She is now a Clinical Pharmacist with Providence Health Care and a student in the graduate Doctor of Pharmacy program at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia.
BSc(Pharm), ACPR, PharmD, is a Clinical Pharmacy Specialist, Transplant, with Providence Health Care, and a Clinical Assistant Professor with the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia.
Can J Hosp Pharm. 2016 Mar-Apr;69(2):114-21. doi: 10.4212/cjhp.v69i2.1538. Epub 2016 Apr 29.
Disturbances in hemostasis are common among renal transplant recipients. Because of the risk of thromboembolism and graft loss after transplant, a prophylactic heparin protocol was implemented at St Paul's Hospital in Vancouver, British Columbia, in 2011. Therapeutic heparin is sometimes prescribed perioperatively for patients with preexisting prothrombotic conditions. There is currently limited literature on the safety and efficacy of heparin use in the early postoperative period.
The primary objectives were to document, for patients who underwent renal transplant, the incidence of major bleeding and of thrombosis in those receiving therapeutic heparin, prophylactic heparin, and no heparin anticoagulation in the early postoperative period and to compare these rates for the latter 2 groups. The secondary objectives included a comparison of the risk factors associated with major bleeding and thrombosis.
Adult patients who received a renal transplant at St Paul's Hospital between January 2008 and July 2013 were included in this retrospective cohort study. Electronic health records and databases were used to divide patients into the 3 heparin-use cohorts, to identify cases of major bleeding and thrombosis, and to characterize patients and events. The Fisher exact test was used for the primary outcome analysis, and descriptive statistics were used for all other outcomes.
A total of 547 patients were included in the analysis. Major bleeding was observed in 6 (46%) of the 13 patients who received therapeutic heparin; no cases of thrombosis occurred in these patients. Major bleeding occurred in 8 (3.0%) of the 266 patients who received prophylactic heparin and 9 (3.4%) of the 268 who received no heparin (p > 0.99). Thrombosis occurred in 1 (0.4%) and 3 (1.1%) of these patients, respectively (p = 0.62). Major bleeding occurred more frequently among patients with a low-target heparin protocol, but 61% of values for partial thromboplastin time were above target. A larger proportion of deceased-donor transplant recipients who had major bleeding were taking antiplatelet agents, relative to living-donor transplant recipients.
Therapeutic use of heparin increased the risk of bleeding among renal transplant recipients, but there were no cases of thrombosis. Prophylactic use of heparin did not increase the risk of bleeding and prevented proportionately more cases of thrombosis relative to no anticoagulation; this result supports the continued use of prophylaxis.
止血功能紊乱在肾移植受者中很常见。由于移植后存在血栓栓塞和移植肾丢失的风险,2011年不列颠哥伦比亚省温哥华圣保罗医院实施了预防性肝素方案。对于术前已存在血栓形成倾向的患者,有时会在围手术期使用治疗性肝素。目前关于术后早期使用肝素的安全性和有效性的文献有限。
主要目的是记录肾移植患者在术后早期接受治疗性肝素、预防性肝素和未接受肝素抗凝治疗的患者中大出血和血栓形成的发生率,并比较后两组的发生率。次要目的包括比较与大出血和血栓形成相关的危险因素。
本回顾性队列研究纳入了2008年1月至2013年7月在圣保罗医院接受肾移植的成年患者。使用电子健康记录和数据库将患者分为3个肝素使用队列,确定大出血和血栓形成的病例,并对患者和事件进行特征描述。主要结局分析采用Fisher精确检验,所有其他结局采用描述性统计。
共有547例患者纳入分析。接受治疗性肝素的13例患者中有6例(46%)发生大出血;这些患者未发生血栓形成病例。接受预防性肝素的266例患者中有8例(3.0%)发生大出血,未接受肝素的268例患者中有9例(3.4%)发生大出血(p>0.99)。这些患者中分别有1例(0.4%)和3例(1.1%)发生血栓形成(p=0.62)。低目标肝素方案的患者大出血发生率更高,但部分凝血活酶时间值61%高于目标值。与活体供肾移植受者相比,发生大出血的死亡供肾移植受者服用抗血小板药物的比例更高。
肝素的治疗性使用增加了肾移植受者出血的风险,但未发生血栓形成病例。预防性使用肝素并未增加出血风险,与未进行抗凝治疗相比,预防血栓形成的病例比例更高;这一结果支持继续使用预防性治疗。