Lloyd Mark Sheldon, Lafferty Kirsten, Horton Johan, Noons Peter, Dover Stephen, Evans Martin
Department of Craniofacial Surgery, Birmingham Children's Hospital, Birmingham, UK.
J Craniofac Surg. 2016 Jun;27(4):874-5. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000002623.
Parental anxiety may be caused by inappropriate information on the world wide web regarding craniosynostosis. The aim of this study was to study the correlation between the first 100 websites ranked on the Google search engine and those ranked based on objective scoring with patient information scoring tool. The results of these findings can then be used to recommend websites based on the quality of information that may not initially appear first on a search engine.
The DISCERN patient information scoring tool was chosen as a scientific way of measuring the quality of patient information based on previous research by the Picker Institute in Oxford. The word "craniosynostosis" was entered into the Google internet search engine. Patient information provided by the first 100 websites was studied and scored using the DISCERN scoring tool. From this score, each website was ranked with the highest scoring website at the top and worse scoring website at the bottom. This ranking based on the DISCERN tool score was correlated against the ranking of the website by Google. Positive correlation between DISCERN and Google ranking would be demonstrated if a website high in the ranking using DISCERN was also at the top of the first 100 websites on Google.
No correlation could be found between those websites ranked highly for patient information on craniosynostosis using the DISCERN tool to the ranking provided by Google. DISCERN scores ranged from 17 to 72 (the lowest possible DISCERN tool score being 15 and the highest 85). The website ranking highest in terms of quality appeared only 50th in the Google rank.
High-quality patient information on craniosynostosis does exist on the world wide web but may be difficult to find due to the complexity of factors used to rank websites on internet search engines. This results in some high-quality websites not appearing at the top of an internet search. Therefore, parents risk missing useful information relevant to their child's diagnosis. Healthcare professionals can use objective scoring of patient information websites to empower their patients to seek higher quality information.
家长的焦虑可能源于万维网上关于颅缝早闭的不恰当信息。本研究的目的是探究在谷歌搜索引擎上排名前100的网站与使用患者信息评分工具进行客观评分后排名的网站之间的相关性。这些研究结果随后可用于根据信息质量推荐网站,这些网站可能在搜索引擎上最初不会排在首位。
基于牛津皮克研究所之前的研究,选择DISCERN患者信息评分工具作为衡量患者信息质量的科学方法。在谷歌互联网搜索引擎中输入“颅缝早闭”一词。使用DISCERN评分工具对前100个网站提供的患者信息进行研究和评分。根据该分数,对每个网站进行排名,得分最高的网站排在首位,得分较低的网站排在末尾。基于DISCERN工具分数的这种排名与谷歌对网站的排名进行相关性分析。如果使用DISCERN排名靠前的网站也在谷歌的前100个网站中名列前茅,则表明DISCERN与谷歌排名之间存在正相关。
使用DISCERN工具对颅缝早闭患者信息排名靠前的网站与谷歌提供的排名之间未发现相关性。DISCERN分数范围为17至72(DISCERN工具的最低可能分数为15,最高为85)。在质量方面排名最高的网站在谷歌排名中仅位列第50。
万维网上确实存在关于颅缝早闭的高质量患者信息,但由于用于在互联网搜索引擎上对网站进行排名的因素复杂,可能难以找到。这导致一些高质量网站未出现在互联网搜索结果的顶部。因此,家长有错过与孩子诊断相关有用信息的风险。医疗保健专业人员可以使用患者信息网站的客观评分,帮助患者获取更高质量的信息。