Celik Onur, Eskiizmir Gorkem, Pabuscu Yuksel, Ulkumen Burak, Toker Gokce Tanyeri
Celal Bayar University, School of Medicine, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Manisa, Turkey.
Celal Bayar University, School of Medicine, Department of Radiology, Manisa, Turkey.
Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2017 May-Jun;83(3):261-268. doi: 10.1016/j.bjorl.2016.03.016. Epub 2016 Apr 29.
The exact etiology of Bell's palsy still remains obscure. The only authenticated finding is inflammation and edema of the facial nerve leading to entrapment inside the facial canal.
To identify if there is any relationship between the grade of Bell's palsy and diameter of the facial canal, and also to study any possible anatomic predisposition of facial canal for Bell's palsy including parts which have not been studied before.
Medical records and temporal computed tomography scans of 34 patients with Bell's palsy were utilized in this retrospective clinical study. Diameters of both facial canals (affected and unaffected) of each patient were measured at labyrinthine segment, geniculate ganglion, tympanic segment, second genu, mastoid segment and stylomastoid foramen. The House-Brackmann (HB) scale of each patient at presentation and 3 months after the treatment was evaluated from their medical records. The paired samples t-test and Wilcoxon signed-rank test were used for comparison of width between the affected side and unaffected side. The Wilcoxon signed-rank test was also used for evaluation of relationship between the diameter of facial canal and the grade of the Bell's palsy. Significant differences were established at a level of p=0.05 (IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 21.0.; Armonk, NY, IBM Corp).
Thirty-four patients - 16 females, 18 males; mean age±Standard Deviation, 40.3±21.3 - with Bell's palsy were included in the study. According to the HB facial nerve grading system; 8 patients were grade V, 6 were grade IV, 11 were grade III, 8 were grade II and 1 patient was grade I. The mean width at the labyrinthine segment of the facial canal in the affected temporal bone was significantly smaller than the equivalent in the unaffected temporal bone (p=0.00). There was no significant difference between the affected and unaffected temporal bones at the geniculate ganglion (p=0.87), tympanic segment (p=0.66), second genu (p=0.62), mastoid segment (p=0.67) and stylomastoid foramen (p=0.16). We did not find any relationship between the HB grade and the facial canal diameter at the level of labyrinthine segment (p=0.41), tympanic segment (p=0.12), mastoid segment (p=0.14), geniculate ganglion (p=0.13) and stylomastoid foramen (p=0.44), while we found significant relationship at the level of second genu (p=0.02).
We found the diameter of labyrinthine segment of facial canal as an anatomic risk factor for Bell's palsy. We also found significant relationship between the HB grade and FC diameter at the level of second genu. Future studies (MRI-CT combined or 3D modeling) are needed to promote this possible relevance especially at second genu. Thus, in the future it may be possible to selectively decompress particular segments in high grade BP patients.
贝尔面瘫的确切病因仍不明确。唯一经证实的发现是面神经的炎症和水肿导致其在面神经管内受压。
确定贝尔面瘫的分级与面神经管直径之间是否存在关联,并研究面神经管对于贝尔面瘫是否存在任何可能的解剖学易患因素,包括此前未被研究过的部位。
本回顾性临床研究使用了34例贝尔面瘫患者的病历和颞部计算机断层扫描。测量了每位患者双侧面神经管(患侧和健侧)在迷路段、膝状神经节、鼓室段、第二膝部、乳突段和茎乳孔处的直径。从病历中评估每位患者就诊时及治疗后3个月的House - Brackmann(HB)分级。采用配对样本t检验和Wilcoxon符号秩检验比较患侧和健侧的宽度。Wilcoxon符号秩检验还用于评估面神经管直径与贝尔面瘫分级之间的关系。在p = 0.05水平确定显著差异(IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows,版本21.0;纽约州阿蒙克,IBM公司)。
34例贝尔面瘫患者纳入研究,其中女性16例,男性18例;平均年龄±标准差为40.3±21.3岁。根据HB面神经分级系统,8例为V级,6例为IV级,11例为III级,8例为II级,1例为I级。患侧颞骨面神经管迷路段的平均宽度显著小于健侧颞骨(p = 0.00)。在膝状神经节(p = 0.87)、鼓室段(p = 0.66)、第二膝部(p = 0.62)、乳突段(p = 0.67)和茎乳孔(p = 0.16)处,患侧和健侧颞骨之间无显著差异。我们未发现迷路段(p = 0.41)、鼓室段(p = 0.12)、乳突段(p = 0.14)、膝状神经节(p = 0.13)和茎乳孔(p = 0.44)水平的HB分级与面神经管直径之间存在关联,而在第二膝部水平发现了显著关联(p = 0.02)。
我们发现面神经管迷路段直径是贝尔面瘫的解剖学危险因素。我们还发现第二膝部水平的HB分级与面神经管直径之间存在显著关联。未来需要进一步研究(MRI - CT联合或三维建模)以促进这种可能的关联,特别是在第二膝部。因此,未来有可能对重度贝尔面瘫患者的特定节段进行选择性减压治疗。