Harris John A, Herrel Lindsey A, Healy Mark A, Wancata Lauren M, Perumalswami Chithra R
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Clinical Scholars Program, Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation, and Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Dow Division of Urologic Health Services Research, Department of Urology, and Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2016 Sep;52(3):345-352.e5. doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2016.03.007. Epub 2016 Jun 1.
Primary palliative care (PPC) skills are useful in a wide variety of medical and surgical specialties, and the expectations of PPC skill training are unknown across graduate medical education.
We characterized the variation and quality of PPC skills in residency outcomes-based Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) milestones.
We performed a content analysis with structured implicit review of 2015 ACGME milestone documents from 14 medical and surgical specialties chosen for their exposure to clinical situations requiring PPC. For each specialty milestone document, we characterized the variation and quality of PPC skills in residency outcomes-based ACGME milestones.
We identified 959 occurrences of 29 palliative search terms within 14 specialty milestone documents. Within these milestone documents, implicit review characterized 104 milestones with direct saliency to PPC skills and 196 milestones with indirect saliency. Initial interrater agreement of the saliency rating among the primary reviewers was 89%. Specialty milestone documents varied widely in their incorporation of PPC skills within milestone documents. PPC milestones were most commonly found in milestone documents for Anesthesiology, Pediatrics, Urology, and Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. PPC-relevant milestones were most commonly found in the Interpersonal and Communication Skills core competency with 108 (36%) relevant milestones classified under this core competency.
Future revisions of specialty-specific ACGME milestone documents should focus on currently underrepresented, but important PPC skills.
初级姑息治疗(PPC)技能在多种医学和外科专业中都很有用,而研究生医学教育中对PPC技能培训的期望尚不清楚。
我们在基于住院医师培训结果的毕业后医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)的里程碑中,对PPC技能的差异和质量进行了描述。
我们对14个医学和外科专业的2015年ACGME里程碑文件进行了结构化隐式审查的内容分析,这些专业因其接触到需要PPC的临床情况而被选中。对于每个专业的里程碑文件,我们在基于住院医师培训结果的ACGME里程碑中描述了PPC技能的差异和质量。
我们在14个专业里程碑文件中识别出29个姑息治疗相关术语的959次出现。在这些里程碑文件中,隐式审查确定了104个对PPC技能有直接显著意义的里程碑和196个有间接显著意义的里程碑。主要评审员之间对显著程度评分的初始评分者间一致性为89%。各专业里程碑文件在将PPC技能纳入里程碑文件方面差异很大。PPC里程碑最常见于麻醉学、儿科学、泌尿学以及物理医学与康复的里程碑文件中。与PPC相关的里程碑最常见于人际和沟通技能核心能力中,有108个(36%)相关里程碑归类于该核心能力之下。
ACGME特定专业里程碑文件的未来修订应关注目前未得到充分体现但很重要的PPC技能。