Gravina Silvia, Dong Xiao, Yu Bo, Vijg Jan
Department of Genetics, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Michael F. Price Center, 1301 Morris Park Avenue, Bronx, NY, 10461, USA.
Present address: Illumina Inc, San Diego, CA, 92122, USA.
Genome Biol. 2016 Jul 5;17(1):150. doi: 10.1186/s13059-016-1011-3.
Transmission fidelity of CpG DNA methylation patterns is not foolproof, with error rates from less than 1 to well over 10 % per CpG site, dependent on preservation of the methylated or unmethylated state and the type of sequence. This suggests a fairly high chance of errors. However, the consequences of such errors in terms of cell-to-cell variation have never been demonstrated by experimentally measuring intra-tissue heterogeneity in an adult organism.
We employ single-cell DNA methylomics to analyze heterogeneity of genome-wide 5-methylcytosine (5mC) patterns within mouse liver. Our results indicate a surprisingly high level of heterogeneity, corresponding to an average epivariation frequency of approximately 3.3 %, with regions containing H3K4me1 being the most variable and promoters and CpG islands the most stable. Our data also indicate that the level of 5mC heterogeneity is dependent on genomic features. We find that non-functional sites such as repeat elements and introns are mostly unstable and potentially functional sites such as gene promoters are mostly stable.
By employing a protocol for whole-genome bisulfite sequencing of single cells, we show that the liver epigenome is highly unstable with an epivariation frequency in DNA methylation patterns of at least two orders of magnitude higher than somatic mutation frequencies.
CpG DNA甲基化模式的传递保真度并非万无一失,每个CpG位点的错误率从不到1%到远超过10%不等,这取决于甲基化或未甲基化状态的保留以及序列类型。这表明错误发生的可能性相当高。然而,从未通过实验测量成年生物体组织内的异质性来证明这种错误在细胞间变异方面的后果。
我们采用单细胞DNA甲基化组学来分析小鼠肝脏内全基因组5-甲基胞嘧啶(5mC)模式的异质性。我们的结果表明异质性水平惊人地高,平均表观变异频率约为3.3%,其中含有H3K4me1的区域变异最大,而启动子和CpG岛最稳定。我们的数据还表明5mC异质性水平取决于基因组特征。我们发现重复元件和内含子等非功能位点大多不稳定,而基因启动子等潜在功能位点大多稳定。
通过采用单细胞全基因组亚硫酸氢盐测序方案,我们表明肝脏表观基因组高度不稳定,其DNA甲基化模式的表观变异频率比体细胞突变频率至少高两个数量级。