Narimani Mahnaz, Seyed Mehdi Seyed Ahmad, Gholami Farshid, Ansari Ladan, Aryafar Mohammad, Shahbazi Fatemeh
J Perianesth Nurs. 2016 Aug;31(4):298-302. doi: 10.1016/j.jopan.2015.08.012. Epub 2016 May 17.
The purpose of the study was to investigate the effect of betamethasone gel and lidocaine jelly (over tracheal tube cuff) compared with distilled water on the postextubation syndrome incidence (sore throat, cough, and hoarseness).
Double-blind randomized clinical trial study was used.
Ninety-nine patients of either sex undergoing elective surgery, under general anesthesia with endotracheal intubation, were recruited. Patients were randomized into three group, betamethasone gel, lidocaine jelly, or distilled water applied on the external surface of the tracheal tube. Patients were assessed for postoperative sore throat, cough, and hoarseness at 1, 6, and 24 hours after surgery.
In the first hour after surgery, the patients who received lidocaine or betamethasone had a significantly greater incidence of sore throat than the patients who received distilled water (RR = 2.9). In the sixth hour after surgery, there was a better effect of distilled water on reducing the incidence of sore throat, but no significant differences between the three groups were seen 24 hours after surgery. The incidence of cough was significantly lower in the distilled water group (P < .02) except at the first and 24 hours postoperative when the incidence of cough was similar. The incidence of hoarseness was similar between the three groups at 1, 6, and 24 hours after surgery.
In this study, the use of lidocaine gel and betamethasone does not reduce the incidence of sore throat or cough after intubation as much as distilled water.
本研究旨在探讨倍他米松凝胶和利多卡因凝胶(气管导管套囊上方)与蒸馏水相比,对拔管后综合征(咽痛、咳嗽和声音嘶哑)发生率的影响。
采用双盲随机临床试验研究。
招募99例接受择期手术、全身麻醉下行气管插管的患者,无论性别。患者被随机分为三组,分别在气管导管外表面涂抹倍他米松凝胶、利多卡因凝胶或蒸馏水。在术后1小时、6小时和24小时对患者进行术后咽痛、咳嗽和声音嘶哑的评估。
术后第1小时,接受利多卡因或倍他米松的患者咽痛发生率显著高于接受蒸馏水的患者(相对危险度=2.9)。术后第6小时,蒸馏水在降低咽痛发生率方面效果更好,但术后24小时三组之间无显著差异。除术后第1小时和24小时咳嗽发生率相似外,蒸馏水组咳嗽发生率显著较低(P<0.02)。术后1小时、6小时和24小时,三组声音嘶哑发生率相似。
在本研究中,使用利多卡因凝胶和倍他米松在降低插管后咽痛或咳嗽发生率方面不如蒸馏水。